Convictions: Slate's blog on legal issues



  • Barack Obama Needs the Wright Stuff To Win—Don't Disown, Embrace Him!


    The Rev. Jeremiah Wright is not your perfect, textbook pastor. He doesn't just stand at the back of the church with innocuous and uninvolved welcomes and goodbyes.

    But the perfect is the enemy of the good. Barack Obama's campaign has been all about showing us how to do good in an imperfect world. How to accept each other as we are, not how we would like each other to be.

    Personally, I don't believe U.S. government is killing my African-American brothers by spreading a virulent disease. Nor would I characterize the actions of the United States in Iraq, which I think deeply flawed, as terrorist. But then, I have never felt entirely comfortable with any of the explanations for the murders of John F. Kennedy or Robert Kennedy or Martin Luther King Jr. Some things are unexplained in life, and sometimes, despite all evidence, we indulge our own narratives to see us through. In her thoughtful column in the Los Angeles Times, Rosa Brooks reminds us that there are significant numbers of black Americans who, because of the Tuskegee experiments where largely black sharecroppers served as human guinea pigs in public health experimentation, do not immediately see the Rev. Wright's comments about AIDS as paranoia.

    Even if Sen. Obama is not prepared to rationalize the Rev. Wright's suspicions, he should forgive him. Yes, it's important to talk about the economy and health care and ending the war, but without reconciliation with the Rev. Wright, the campaign will be off-kilter. The Obama campaign has always been more about the Christian ethic of love of neighbor than wonkish policy. Whatever voice Jeremiah Wright used in his sermons, he successfully strengthened that aspect of Barack Obama's gifted personality. To disown or to separate from Jeremiah Wright is to distance himself from himself. It can't be done, and in any event, it's politically unwise.

    Some have written that Jeremiah Wright is the missing father figure in Sen. Obama's life. I'm no psychologist, but that makes sense. I know at times I have embarrassed my sons. My father, who is nearing 86 and has all the endearing and frustrating qualities of that age, at times has embarrassed me. It is what fathers and sons do. Barack Obama might have known that if his Kenyan father had not left too soon. More importantly, it would have been easier for him to recognize that only the mean-spirited or small-minded seeking political advantage would insist upon a division between father and son.

    No, Sen. Obama, you don't have to distance yourself from your lifelong friend to be elected president of the United States. It is wrong for any of us to ask you to do so, and it would be a mistake for you to yield. So, call him up. Invite him out to Indiana. Kick back together with the Hoosiers, and if you have the time, stop in to see another Father—Theodore Hesburgh, C.S.C., Notre Dame's president emeritus and inspirational civil rights leader.  The three of you are sharing a historic journey, and there's no good reason for anyone to sit at the back of the bus or be thrown under it.

  • The Shunning


    First, Sen. Obama sort of half-shunned Jeremiah Wright—the video clips don't do justice to the man's good work as I knew it; then Wright surprise-shunned Obama—he's just a politician doin' what politicians do, which prompted Obama to double-shun Wright—say what again about roosting terrorist chickens and the government's spread of HIV? Not to be outdone, Bob Novak wants the Catholic Church to shun a good chunk of the Democratic congressional leadership by excluding them from communion.

    This primary has definitely gone on much too long. I know it's not over until the Howard Dean screams, but. please, must we wait until November?

    Sen. Obama—let the good Rev. Wright play out the "crazy Uncle Harry" routine; in this case, you are definitely not your brother's keeper.

    And Mr. Novak, "judge not lest ye be judged and found unworthy."

    So, now that we have transcended the politics of race and division, what's next?

Print This ArticlePRINT Discuss in the FrayDISCUSS
<November 2009>
SMTWTFS
25262728293031
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293012345
Join the Fray: our reader discussion forum
What did you think of this article?
POST A MESSAGE | READ MESSAGES

Syndication