Donald Trump claims there is no drought in California.

In California, Trump Takes Denial to New Lows: "There Is No Drought"

In California, Trump Takes Denial to New Lows: "There Is No Drought"

Bad Astronomy
The entire universe in blog form
May 30 2016 9:00 AM

Lies Trump Reality

Dry river bed in California
This is what sufficient water looks like to Donald Trump, apparently.

Shutterstock / nvelichko

At this point, it’s painfully clear that Donald Trump is incapable of telling the truth. Listening to him talk is actually rather amazing; just by the laws of statistics he should randomly say something accurate just once, at least by accident.

Yet, here we are.

Advertisement

On Friday, May 27, 2016, Trump was in Fresno, California to give a stump speech. In it, he talked about water and California’s enduring drought… or did he? If you listen to him, he doesn't seem to think it’s a problem.

Here's what he said:

When I just left, 50 or 60 farmers in the back and they can’t get water. And I say, “How tough is it; how bad is the drought?” “There is no drought, they turn the water out into the ocean.” And I said I’ve been hearing it and I spent a half an hour with them it’s hard to believe.

Now it’s a little tough to parse that quotation, because he talks as if periods between sentences are a liberal conspiracy. A lot of people are quoting him as if he is saying there is no drought, but it could be that the “There is no drought” line is him quoting the farmers he was talking to. However, given the context, it’s clear he thinks this as well. Also in the full speech you can hear him quoting a farmer saying, “There’s plenty of water”.

Advertisement

Where to even start with something so bizarrely nonsensical? To believe there’s plenty of water in California you’d either have to be a cactus or completely, utterly oblivious to reality. Because that’s grossly wrong. Grotesquely wrong.

drought
"There is no drought." Oh, really?

David Simeral, Western Regional Climate Center

California is suffering a massive drought, and has been for years. As that graphic above shows, 95 percent of the state is at least abnormally dry, and over 20 percent is having an “exceptional drought”. That’s better than last year when over 40 percent of the state was exceptionally dry; a better snow pack in the Sierra Nevadas this year has helped in northern California somewhat. Still, many of the reservoirs are below average levels; some far below, and the southern part of the state is in dire straits (so to speak). Things are not good, and projections show the drought will persist through at least August. Probably far longer.

So Trump’s claim that there’s plenty of water is just more of the lies he’s peddling.

Part of what he’s talking about in that speech deals with water being diverted from farms to rivers to protect wildlife such as the delta smelt and salmon. That’s a very complicated and thorny issue, and I don’t pretend to have an answer here. But Trump certainly doesn’t either, and simply saying, “If I win, believe me, we’re going to start opening up the water so that you can have your farmers survive,” as Trump did in his speech, is ridiculous. The laws won’t let him do that, for one thing, and for another it’s unlikely to help in the long run. California simply doesn’t have an infinite supply of water.

Advertisement

This is a situation that calls for a lot of political compromise, nuance, and long-term thinking. Trump has none of that.

Phil Plait Phil Plait

Phil Plait writes Slate’s Bad Astronomy blog and is an astronomer, public speaker, science evangelizer, and author of Death From the Skies!  

You know what else this situation needs? At the very least, an acknowledgment that climate change is real. Environmental scientist Peter Gleick and climatologist Michael Mann wrote a commentary in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, saying there is “accumulating evidence that anthropogenic climatic changes are already influencing the frequency, magnitude, and duration of drought in California.”

Yet Trump denies climate change even exists. He hired a flat-out denier as his energy advisor, and has made it clear he thinks global warming is a hoax.

Later on in his speech, talking about the water shortage and getting more water to the farmers, Trump had this to say: “We’re gonna get it done. We’re gonna get it done quick. Don’t even think about it.”

Indeed, that should be his motto. “Don’t even think about it.” Because, apparently, that’s the last thing he wants anyone listening to him to do.