Video: ESA tests high-speed impactor probe.
Video: ESA Tests High-Speed Impactor Probe
Bad Astronomy
The entire universe in blog form
Aug. 24 2013 9:00 AM

How to Ram a Planet

high speed impact test
A frame from the high-speed impact test video. The 20-kg projectile is blue, and this shows it about 3 milliseconds before it hit the blocks of ice on the right.

Photo by Qinetiq/ESA

Some of the most interesting things in the solar system lie just beneath the surface of its worlds. At mid-latitudes, Mars has water ice just centimeters below the surface dust and rocks. Europa is a frozen moon of Jupiter, an ice shell wrapped around a global ocean. Enceladus, a moon of Saturn, is much the same. Comets, too, have ice located just beneath their thin rock veneer, and some asteroids almost certainly have ice deposits in them.

Phil Plait Phil Plait

Phil Plait writes Slate’s Bad Astronomy blog and is an astronomer, public speaker, science evangelizer, and author of Death From the Skies!  

Getting past the surface and into the interesting bits poses a problem, though. Digging is hard, and melting means access to a lot of energy that’s difficult to provide on a space probe. So why not take a more direct approach?


Ram them!

Literally: Send a probe at high speed into the surface of your target to break on through to the other side. You have to build them tough, and your instruments have to withstand a whopping great acceleration. But it’s possible, and the European Space Agency is testing high-speed impactors now. They just released this great video of a test, where they slammed a 20 kilogram (45 pound) “penetrator” into ten tons of ice at a whopping 341 meters per second—760 miles per hour, just under the speed of sound:

That is so cool! And impressive: the penetrator got whacked as it hit the top of the enclosure, but survived with just a dent, despite being subjected to a savage 24,000 g of deceleration. Not sure what that means? It’s hundreds of times the acceleration that would kill a human being.

I rode in a fighter jet and we got over 5 g briefly, and while it wasn’t lethal, it wasn’t exactly fun. 24,000 g is mind-numbing, But we can make things that survive it. I’ll note this is simply a test of technology, and there aren’t any current plans to use this type of probe to explore the planets.

So who knows? If there are fishies swimming under some permanently-frozen moon of an outer world, or secrets locked up in the interiors of Mars or comets or asteroids, our first glimpse of them may come from some instrument capable of withstanding years of traveling in vacuum, hard radiation from the Sun, and then a final, severe blow before finding rest… and maybe also finding some answers to some very curious questions.

[Update (Sep. 30, 2013): Slate has posted a new video with a lot more information and different camera angles on the impact test.]

  Slate Plus
Hang Up And Listen
Dec. 1 2015 3:21 PM The “Violating His Amateur Status” Bonus Segment The Hang Up and Listen hosts cover speedcubing—from the algorithms of Rubik’s Cubes to the sport’s record-breaking competitors.