BREAKING: Cuccinelli's climate change case dismissed

The entire universe in blog form
Aug. 30 2010 11:00 AM

BREAKING: Cuccinelli's climate change case dismissed

kencuccinelliI've written quite a bit about Ken Cuccinelli, the Virginia State Attorney General who has been pursuing a witch hunt case against climate scientist Michael Mann (see "Related Posts" at the bottom of this post). Cuccinelli claims that while Mann was working at the University of Virginia, he was wasting taxpayer money researching global warming. Cuccinelli has subpoenaed files relating to Mann's work. You can just guess how I feel about that (if you say it makes my irony gland explode, you win).

I just found out that a judge in this case has dismissed Cuccinelli's subpoeana. The good news:

Phil Plait Phil Plait

Phil Plait writes Slate’s Bad Astronomy blog and is an astronomer, public speaker, science evangelizer, and author of Death From the Skies!  

Advertisement

Cuccinelli did not show, [Judge] Peatross wrote, any evidence that Mann’s work was "misleading, false or fraudulent in obtaining funds from the Commonwealth of Virginia."

The bad news is that the judge left the door open for Cuccinelli to file more demands to obtain research documents. This sort of thing puts a chill on freedom of academic research, which is why UVa has fought so hard against Cuccinelli. Given that Thomas Jefferson founded UVa, the irony factor in this situation is very high indeed.

In the end, I don't think Cuccinelli is going to get any traction with this case, except perhaps politically. He has been - haha - feeling the heat about this recently. No fewer than four science/free speech advocacy groups filed an amicus brief against Cuccinelli, there have been numerous press releases by the Union of Concerned Scientists (a group I am hit or miss with, but on this they've nailed it), and - while it was unrelated to this case specifically - the EPA has chimed in, rejecting anti-global warming claims.

Cuccinelli is a climate change denier, plain and simple. His attack against Mann was ill-advised and based on nothing but noise. After all the overwhelming evidence against his claims, if Cuccinelli continues to pursue this case I hope people come to realize who is really wasting taxpayers' money.



Related posts: