Like all right-thinking Americans, I was delighted when Jay McCarroll took top honors on this week's finale of Project Runway. How could you not root for Jay the joy-bomb, the big gay goofball from rural Pennsylvania? He had a buoyant sense of humor, a wacked-out personal style (The serapes! The square pink sunglasses! That one time he dressed as Jesus!) and a true artist's quiet confidence in his own vision. Remember that exquisite Chrysler Building dress he pulled off in Week 3? And how he rose above the petty sniping of the final days by simply informing his arch-nemesis, with gleeful candor, "Everybody hates you"? From now on, whenever I find myself in a viper's nest of backstabbing bitches, I'm going to ask myself, What would Jay do?
Here's hoping the beloved, but endangered, Project Runway makes it to a second season. It's the reality-show-hater's reality show, perhaps because, as Amanda Fortini has observed in these pages, it's about something that's disappearing from our TV screens as well as our culture: craftsmanship, the ability to take material objects and transform them for our own use. But I didn't realize how much there is to admire about people like Jay— people who can actually make stuff— until I caught a few wretched minutes of last night's Jennifer Lopez: Beyond the Runway, an MTV infomercial— excuse me, documentary— about the launching of J. Lo's new sportswear line. Like the Project Runway finale, J. Lo's launch took place over Fashion Week this month in New York; MTV's cameras followed the seven-month runup to the show, watching designers, models, perfumiers, and hangers-on scurry to and fro, proffering swatches and buttons as they awaited the next temper tantrum from She Who Must Be Obeyed. The staff studiedly avoided each others' gaze as J. Lo sailed in, clad in furs and low-rise jeans, to harass her wan underlings for not working fast enough to create a "visionary" clothing line she could attach her name to without being "embarrassed." After one Lopezian chewing-out, a staff member ventures meekly, "Well, what do you think of the themes for fall?" "I was the one who came up with the themes for fall!" La Lopez snaps. At this point, any self-respecting reality show would have cut away to the downcast poker face of whoever the real designer was, but Beyond the Runway— produced by Jennifer Lopez! Brought to you by J. Lo's new fragrance, "Miami Glow"!— had a vested interest in positioning Lopez as a bundle of entrepreneurial moxie.
But J. Lo's daily calendar wasn't all about stealing the ideas of her harried flacks: "Sometimes," she explained, "I have to take a break and, like, smell stuff." After a bitchy sniffing session with the developers of "Miami Glow" (now that's what I want to smell like—someone sweating in South Florida), she swans out after informing the miserable perfumier, "This smells a little like Skin So Soft."
If Project Runway does make it back for another season (Please, Lauren Zalaznick! Please!), I have an idea: Let's lock J. Lo and Jay-Mac in the basement of the Parsons School of Design with a pair of scissors, a sewing machine, and $300 worth of remaindered muslin. And may the best craftsman (or woman) win.
Wednesday, Feb. 23, 2005
Since I live in the filthy-minded New York market, I got to see the unsanitized version of last night's controversialFrontline documentary, A Company of Soldiers (though even here, the show's broadcast time was pushed from 9 to 10 p.m. to avoid risking FCC indecency fines). I wonder which of the program's curse words were cut in those PBS markets that showed the "clean" version? Was it when the soldier said, "Holy crap!" upon seeing the massive hole left on the side of the road by a car bomb? When a commanding officer, realizing that an Iraqi civilian writhing in the back of a taxi is fatally wounded and beyond help, softly murmurs, "God damn it"? Then, after a Humvee explodes and one of men takes shrapnel to the ear, I guess they'd have to bleep out his panicked buddy yelling, "Pull fucking security!" What about the gunner discussing the death of two friends from his unit, who observes chillingly that, "My job is not to die for my country; my job is to make the other poor bastard die for his country"? Is the word "bastard" on the FCC list of naughty no-nos? (Scroll down to section III. A.1 for the good bits.)
After watching the 90 grueling minutes of A Company of Soldiers, it's hard to believe that anyone would be more concerned with what the members of Dog Company in South Baghdad are saying than with what's actually happening to them. After watching the show, I spoke to David Fanning, Frontline's executive producer, about PBS's decision to reverse their usual policy of airing potentially offensive material on the nationwide "hard feed," while making a sanitized version available on demand to those local markets that preferred it. Last night, the default version of A Company of Soldiers—the one available on 300 out of the 350 PBS stations nationwide—was the expurgated one. But though Fanning sent out a memo last week protesting PBS's decision and stating that "this is the moment for public television to stand firm and broadcast 'A Company of Soldiers' intact," he says he understands the network's plight as well.
After all, he pointed out, if every PBS station had run the unedited version of A Company of Soldiers at 9 p.m. ET last night as scheduled, the potential fines across the country could have added up in the $90 million range. Under a new bill just passed by the House, the current cap of a maximum $27,500 fine per show could be increased to as much as $3 million per network per day. For the sake of comparison, the average episode of Frontline, Fanning estimates, costs around $400,000 to produce, and many local PBS stations operate on an annual budget of not much more than that. Michael Powell might not let you say these words in prime time, but the FCC has public television by the balls.
Bill Reed, the manager of KCPT, a PBS station in Kansas City that chose to run the program unedited in its original time slot and risk the fine, has compared the current broadcasting climate to the Red Scare of the 1950s: "You have to go back to the McCarthy era to get a feel for how far this has gone." When I asked Fanning if that was overstating the case, he grew thoughtful, saying, "Acomparison is valid in that a minority of people have brought their values to bear on public standards." But Fanning was most worried about the intangible muzzling effect that the current climate of fear will have on producers of future shows, who are more likely to censor themselves in terms of program content. He cited a well-known 1985 episode of Frontline, Memory of the the Camps, which included never-before-seen footage from the liberation of German concentration camps in 1945. If that documentary were to air today, could images of nude prisoners fall under the FCC prohibition against "obscene, profane and indecent broadcasts"?
I asked Fanning if there was anything else viewers should know about the FCC's increasingly long shadow on the broadcast television landscape. He stressed the anachronistic quality of the commission itself: "We're trapped in an old structure here, of the regulation of broadcasting vs. the unregulatedness of cable." The current concern with obscenity in broadcasting, in Fanning's opinion, is "a surrogate for the larger cultural war ... a small group of outspoken voices are holding public TV hostage to these pressures from the Hill. It is so deeply contrary to what public broadcasting should be [...]. We have laws that don't allow the Voice of America in the US for a reason ... public broadcasting needs a funding mechanism that shields it from interference."
TODAY IN SLATE
The Right Target
Why Obama’s airstrikes against ISIS may be more effective than people expect.
The One National Holiday Republicans Hope You Forget
It’s Legal for Obama to Bomb Syria Because He Says It Is
I Stand With Emma Watson on Women’s Rights
Even though I know I’m going to get flak for it.
Should You Recline Your Seat? Two Economists Weigh In.
It Is Very, Very Stupid to Compare Hope Solo to Ray Rice
Or, why it is very, very stupid to compare Hope Solo to Ray Rice.
In Defense of HR
Startups and small businesses shouldn’t skip over a human resources department.