High-end dog shows are booming in China despite global outrage over an annual dog meat festival.

China’s High-End Dog Shows Are Booming, but Not Without Controversy

China’s High-End Dog Shows Are Booming, but Not Without Controversy

Stories from Roads & Kingdoms
Feb. 5 2016 12:40 PM

China’s Top Dogs

A growing number of Chinese pups and their owners are competing in high-end dog shows, but not without controversy.

Dog 3.
Photos post-competition with judge Christopher Neale.

Jamie Tan

Each week, Roads & Kingdoms and Slate publish a new dispatch from around the globe. For more foreign correspondence mixed with food, war, travel, and photography, visit their online magazine or follow @roadskingdoms on Twitter.

HENGDIAN, China—At 8 a.m. under a cloudless blue sky, visitors streamed onto the grounds of Hengdian World Studios, the largest movie back lot in the world. The 330-hectare site sprawls over several sets, each built to resemble certain historical periods or geographical locations: 19th-century Guangzhou, 20th-century Hong Kong, a Qin dynasty palace. It includes a one-to-one scale replica of Beijing’s Forbidden City. The lot’s first movie set was built in 1996 for the movie The Opium War. Subsequently, it has hosted shoots by such famous directors as Zhang Yimou and Chen Kaige.

Advertisement

Located in a small city in Zhejiang province, 200 miles from Shanghai, the back lot is pretty much all Hengdian has going for it. “Go to Hengdian to see the stars,” the studios’ tagline reads, but on this autumn morning, the crowd of tourists making its way to the imitation Tiananmen Gate missed the 27 furry ingénues nearby awaiting their moment in the spotlight.

Under a cluster of red canopies, small tables were set up, equipment unloaded, electric fans and hairdryers plugged in. A golden retriever, a chow chow, and a miniature schnauzer each stood, patient and unflappable, as groomers pored over them with brushes, scissors, sprays, and blowers.

A 12-foot-high banner proclaimed the occasion: “the 367th through 370th installments of the National General Kennel Club’s China National Purebred Dog Super League,” landing at the Hengdian World Studios this weekend.

Held in a different city each week, the Super League had just come from Suzhou and Nantong to the north and would travel through Wuhan, Beijing, Guiyang, and Shanghai in the following weeks. Since the NGKC was established in 2005, its membership has increased every year. In 2015, it had about 3,500 members, mostly commercial breeders. The NGKC has been formally affiliated with the largest kennel club in the world, the American Kennel Club, since 2008.

Dog 4.
Grooming backstage.

Jamie Tan

Advertisement

As China’s middle class has grown, pet ownership has also soared. Approximately 534,000 pets were registered with the Beijing Public Safety Bureau in 2006, rising to more than a million in 2011. In 2015, 100 million pets were registered in China, which means about 1 in 13 people owns a pet. Interest in dog shows has boomed as well: According to Vicky Zhao, the NGKC’s translation department manager, the organization planned more than 400 shows in 2015, up from about 200 in 2012.

At the NGKC Super League, the dogs are called out in turn to the ring, to pose and trot before the judges. After studying each dog, judges rank them according to how well each conforms to the published breed standard. The awards later conferred (e.g.,  best in group, best in show) translate to points. A dog that has earned the requisite number of points from different judges is eligible for the prefix “CH” before its name, indicating that it is a “champion of record.”

Under the canopies—among the grooming equipment, bright squeaking toys, and camper chairs—heavily pregnant Wang Yi and her 3-year-old daughter passed the time on their phone and tablet. Wang and her husband, who live in Huzhou in Zhejiang province, used to own a pet shop but were now moving into commercial breeding. This was their first foray into competitive dog shows, she said, although they had participated in noncompetitive, recreational pet shows over the past six years. Zhao of the NGKC noted that most NGKC members and competitors were commercial breeders. A winning dog bolstered its breeder’s reputation; its offspring could fetch better prices.

At the uncovered arena, the competition was underway. The golden retriever lopped effortlessly around the ring. The bichon frise twinkled along, light and white as marshmallow fluff. The Pekingese, top dog on the NGKC table in 2015, ambled after its handler, its fur coat rippling like a sinuous manta ray. The judges awarded gaudy rosettes of blue, yellow, red, and purple in snappy, businesslike exchanges.

Advertisement

Zhao added that there were a minority of competitors who were not commercial breeders. She compared them with owners of racehorses: They cared about status and ranking, not so much commercial gain.

Manfread Chan, the Hong Kong owner of Golden Leader Kennel, agreed that some people viewed show dogs as a “commodity.” In his case, he said, the kennel was not his primary source of income, and his interest in these competitions was personal, not commercial. He spent most of his morning smoking backstage, emerging now and then to watch his golden retrievers put through their paces by his partner, Lin Shengyang, and an assistant.

When not competing, the dogs rested in crates backstage, where the shade glowed a deep red from the climbing sun. They took the constant grooming, fussing, and manhandling in stride. A perfectly combed spaniel was forbidden to roll over. Clumps of fur floated to the ground.

Dog shows might be beauty contests for dogs, but their human handlers must also be presentable supporting actors. Lin, running alongside Robben the golden retriever in the ring, was carefully put together in a suit and bow tie, slick hair, and black glittering sneakers. In a slim suit and ponytail, Wang’s husband was as impeccable as their miniature schnauzer. The male handlers wore suits, sweating in the heat. Women wore the traditional Chinese qipao.

Advertisement

To complement her Chinese breed, the sturdy chow chow, Yang Ling wore a black qipao with yellow trimming. She was a dog show veteran from Beijing: Her dogs, competing since 2000, have placed top in Chinese and American competitions. In a weeks, they will be at the 140th Westminster Kennel Club dog show in New York.

Dog 1.
Lin Shengyang with golden retriever Robben.

Jamie Tan

Sunburned handlers squeezed into evaporating slivers of shade to watch the competition. Yuan Bao the chow chow was on a stately promenade with Yang; heavy-coated and dignified, it cannot be hurried. Many competitors were familiar with one another after years on the dog-show circuit. They judged the judges of their dogs. “What kind of judge is this?” groused an aggrieved handler. “He barely looked at the dog!”

This weekend in Hengdian marked the conclusion of Patti Neale’s third visit to China and the first visit of her husband, Christopher Neale. Based in Florida, the Neales are breeders of borzois as well as two of the judges invited to judge this weekend’s NGKC Super League.

Patti Neale visited China for the first time in 2012, when she was invited to Beijing to celebrate the cementing of NGKC and AKC’s relationship, which established the AKC Global Services DNA testing for purebred dogs in China. (NGKC members can have the DNA of their purebred dogs tested by AKC and thereafter register and include them in the AKC registry.)

Advertisement

Neale noted that dog shows are still in their infancy in China, but with the rise of the leisure class, “the big money is in China” these days, even for American breeders. In many parts of the world, she and her husband agreed, the sport of dog-showing is struggling to win the attention of young people. In China, they were gratified by the signs that it was a sport on the rise.

In Milan in June, at the Fédération Cynologique Internationale (World Canine Organziation) General Assembly, “a large majority” of the 68 member countries present voted to hold the 2019 FCI World Dog Show in Shanghai. This decision, however, immediately caused an uproar among FCI member countries, as well as within the international dog-lovers community.

The Canadian, Swedish, and Finnish kennel clubs all voiced their concerns and opposition. Kennel clubs and dog lovers alike argued that China should not host the competition until it banned a dog meat festival, observed annually during the summer solstice in the southern city of Yulin in Guangxi province. The festival has been the source of much controversy in recent years, with opponents incensed by the treatment of dogs and supporters arguing for the recognition of different cultural norms.

A petition that circulated online read: “Don’t let China host the 2019 World Dog Show unless it stops Yulin’s dog-meat festivals!” By January, more than 420,000 people had signed it. Meanwhile, a Facebook page named “No for China World Dog Show 2019” had more than 18,000 likes.

Dog 2.
Christopher Neale and the golden retreiver puppy Happy.

Jamie Tan

Advertisement

Christopher Neale said that he knew that no dog he was selling to a Chinese buyer was going to end up on the dinner table. He considered it “old thinking” to assume that all Chinese were dog-meat eaters and that it was a “knee-jerk reaction” to boycott the FCI World Dog Show because of one festival.

Even so, it seemed poor timing for the FCI to announce the 2019 host in June, the very month when the emotions of dog lovers worldwide were boiling over as a result of the Yulin festival. The Finnish Kennel Club issued a statement in August against awarding the 2019 competition to Shanghai, pointing out, “China has only been a full member of the FCI for a few years,” whereas many “FCI member countries have had to wait for years—sometimes decades—before earning the right to host this prestigious show.”

Among the Chinese competitors in Hengdian, there was little interest in discussing the Yulin festival, an event that took place a few months ago hundreds of miles from Hengdian. Yulin and the NGKC Purebred Dog Super League were two different worlds that hardly seemed to intersect. In Hengdian, dogs were picked up after their walks in the fields, their soiled paws washed, their fur blown dry. At noon, handlers worried aloud that the arena’s surface was getting too hot for their dogs’ paws; they were so concerned about the dogs competing under the midday sun that more canopies were moved to the arena to shelter them.

As the event got underway, it began to attract a crowd of curious onlookers, peeling away from their trek to the Forbidden City. It was an appreciative crowd, effusive in its admiration. Young women were felled by the pertness of the Pomeranian, the confectionery of a bichon frise. Photographs were requested and granted. The handlers wore their dogs’ celebrity status lightly, their faces serious and preoccupied. They knew, not least in a place that’s been called China’s Hollywood, that making a star was hard work, and their work was not yet done.