Bob Edwards' colossal Murrow goof.

Media criticism.
Feb. 1 2006 7:04 PM

Bob Edwards' Big Goof

His Murrow biography packages Good Night, and Good Luck'sfib as fact.

Murrow's myth is still wrong
Click image to expand.
Murrow's myth is still wrong

Thanks to George Clooney's docudrama Good Night, and Good Luck, future generations will believe that CBS Inc. Chairman William Paley yanked Edward R. Murrow's program See It Now from its weekly slot in prime time because the company wouldn't take the political heat that followed Murrow's video fanny-whacking Sen. Joseph McCarthy in March 1954.

In my two-parter about Good Night, and Good Luck (one, two), I conceded that a movie based on historical events must compress action in order to tell a story. Many of the shortcuts taken by Clooney and his co-writer, Grant Heslov, are defensible on dramatic grounds, although I questioned their treatment of See It Now'stransfer out of weekly prime time. In fact, the program remained in prime time for another year after the McCarthy coverage.

But a biography cannot avail itself of shortcut excuses, even if it's only 174 pages, such as former NPR broadcaster Bob Edwards' worshipful 2004 biography, Edward R. Murrow and the Birth of Broadcast Journalism. The book's ninth chapter, "See It Not," presents a See It Now timeline identical to the one found in Good Night, and Good Luck. Edwards writes that See It Now sponsor Alcoa dumped the show and CBS removed it from its weekly slot in 1954, promptly after the McCarthy broadcasts. He writes:

The thanks See It Now received for doing the most significant program in broadcast journalism was to lose both its sponsor and its slot in prime time. …

ALCOA announced the dropping of its sponsorship less than two months after the McCarthy broadcast and just days after a program about a small newspaper's story of a land scandal in Texas where ALCOA was expanding operations. Coincidence?

Every Murrow biography and every broadcast history I've consulted agree that the show survived in weekly prime time until 1955 with Alcoa as the sponsor. A.M. Sperber's biography Murrow: His Life and Times (1986) reports that "ALCOA, despite McCarthy rumblings about IRS audits and spending tax dollars to finance the reds, wasn't canceling, keeping up an impassive public stance in the face of a campaign geared to embarrass."

Advertisement

See It Now didn't avoid controversial material in the season after its McCarthy broadcasts, either. In January 1955, Murrow interviewed J. Robert Oppenheimer, "the father of the atomic bomb," about government secrecy. Oppenheimer had recently lost his federal security clearance because of his Communist associations. Sally Bedell Smith succinctly describes Paley's continued support of Murrow in her 1990 biography of the CBS founder, In All His Glory:

Sensing another possible confrontation, Murrow asked Paley to screen the [Oppenheimer] interview. Paley, who normally avoided involvement in news programs before the fact, took a look and agreed to let the program appear intact. Afterwards, right-wing critics once again attacked the network for being too liberal.

Sperber writes that the Alcoa-See It Now "breakup" began in the spring of 1955, when See It Now aired programs about book-banning and a Texas land scandal (May 3, 1955).

There was just too much money to be made with an entertainment program in Murrow's weekly, prime-time slot for Paley to resist moving it, Sperber writes. The number of homes with a TV set had tripled since See It Now first went on the air and the number of affiliates more than doubled. The CEO detailed his plans for See It Now to Murrow in a July 1955 meeting. Sperber writes:

Paley offered instead an all-film series—specials, essentially—one hour apiece or even longer, bigger budgets, more time for preparation, full-length documentaries. CBS would schedule eight or ten a season, in prime time. Murrow asked about the weekly time slot, said [Murrow producer Fred] Friendly, but it was evidently no longer a topic for discussion.

  Slate Plus
Working
Nov. 27 2014 12:31 PM Slate’s Working Podcast: Episode 11 Transcript Read what David Plotz asked a helicopter paramedic about his workday.