Are "Medicare Advantage" cuts Medicare cuts?

How to fix health policy.
Dec. 4 2009 12:52 PM

Ask Doctor Kildare, Part 1

Introducing an occasional series answering real questions from fake people about the Senate floor debate on Obamacare.

TV Guide cover featuring Dr. Kildare.

Click here for a guide to following the health care reform story online.

Dear Dr. Kildare,

The Obama administration and Senate Democrats maintain that health reform's $491 billion in Medicare cuts don't entail benefit cuts to senior citizens. Republicans maintain that it does, citing as Exhibit A projected cuts in the privately-managed Medicare Advantage program. Sen Orrin Hatch, R.-Utah, has introduced an amendment, being debated on the Senate floor right now, to cancel these cuts. Who's right?

Aged and Confused.

Dear Aged and Confused,

There's no dispute that health reform entails $118 billionin cuts to the Medicare Advantage program, and that making these cuts will reduce benefits available to Medicare Advantage participants. But Medicare Advantage participants, who represent about 23 percent of all Medicare recipients, typically receive benefits over and above what's mandated for Medicare recipients who don't participate in Medicare Advantage. According to the White House, private insurers receive on average 14 percent more per enrollee for Medicare Advantage than the federal government would spend in the regular Medicare program. In some places, private insurers receive 20 percent more.

The original idea of Medicare Advantage, which was created in the 2003 bill creating a Medicare drug benefit, was that the private sector could administer Medicare more cheaply than the government. This did not prove to be the case. It was initially the case for the private health maintenance organizations from which Medicare Advantage is descended. These were established in the 1970s, and by law payments to these private HMO were set at 95 percentof ordinary Medicare payments. But Congress gradually raised payments to encourage greater participation in rural areas. Politics eventually dictated in 1997 that Congress raise payments in urban areas, too, and in the 2003 law payments were raised still further for Medicare Advantage, which includes HMOs, Preferred Provider Organizations, Medical Savings Accounts, and a variety of other types of health insurance plans.

The government's Medicare Payment Advisory Commission concluded in a June 2009 report, "Paying more than [the federal government] is unfair to taxpayers and beneficiaries not enrolled in [Medicare Advantage] plans who subsidize those payments." My recomendation, therefore, is to ignore Sen. Hatch's self-righteous posturing. You'll still be aged, but you'll stop being confused.

James Kildare, M.D.



Crying Rape

False rape accusations exist, and they are a serious problem.

Scotland Votes to Remain in U.K.

There’s a Way to Keep Ex-Cons Out of Prison That Pays for Itself. Why Don’t More States Use It?

The Music Industry Is Ignoring Some of the Best Black Women Singing R&B

Can Democrats Keep Counting on Republicans to Offend Women as a Campaign Strategy?


Theo’s Joint and Vanessa’s Whiskey

No sitcom did the “Very Special Episode” as well as The Cosby Show.


The Other Huxtable Effect

Thirty years ago, The Cosby Show gave us one of TV’s great feminists.

Cliff Huxtable Explains the World: Five Lessons From TV’s Greatest Dad

Why Television Needs a New Cosby Show Right Now

  News & Politics
Sept. 18 2014 8:20 PM A Clever Attempt at Explaining Away a Vote Against the Farm Bill
Sept. 18 2014 6:02 PM A Chinese Company Just Announced the Biggest IPO in U.S. History
Sept. 18 2014 4:15 PM Reactions to a Sketch of Chelsea Manning Reveal Transmisogyny
  Double X
The XX Factor
Sept. 18 2014 12:03 PM The NFL Opines on “the Role of the Female”
  Slate Plus
Behind the Scenes
Sept. 18 2014 1:23 PM “It’s Not Every Day That You Can Beat the World Champion” An exclusive interview with chess grandmaster Fabiano Caruana.
Brow Beat
Sept. 18 2014 3:04 PM Pogo Returns With Another Utterly Catchy Disney Remix
Future Tense
Sept. 18 2014 6:48 PM By 2100 the World's Population Could Be 11 Billion
  Health & Science
Sept. 18 2014 3:35 PM Do People Still Die of Rabies? And how do you know if an animal is rabid?
Sports Nut
Sept. 18 2014 11:42 AM Grandmaster Clash One of the most amazing feats in chess history just happened, and no one noticed.