Donald Trump is a conservative media creation: Right-wing media has engaged in race baiting for years.

Donald Trump Is a Conservative Media Creation

Donald Trump Is a Conservative Media Creation

Who's winning, who's losing, and why.
Nov. 23 2015 6:37 PM

Donald Trump Is a Conservative Media Creation

The real estate mogul’s racist and xenophobic message is a product of years of race-baiting from right-wing media.

151123_POL_Trump-Race-Baiting
Republican presidential candidate Donald Trump speaks during a town hall meeting during a campaign stop at Des Moines Area Community College Newton Campus on Nov. 19, 2015 in Newton, Iowa.

Photo by Scott Olson/Getty Images

Donald Trump has spent most of his campaign indulging and encouraging nativism and anti-immigrant sentiment. When it came to other racial and ethnic groups, however, Trump was silent, even telling crowds that he had a “great relationship with the blacks.” This past weekend, that changed.

Jamelle Bouie Jamelle Bouie

Jamelle Bouie is Slates chief political correspondent.

On Saturday, Trump spoke to thousands at a rally in Birmingham, Alabama. At some point, a local black activist—shouting “Black Lives Matter!—interrupted the event. This prompted a fight, and soon, the activist was on the ground as several men kicked and punched him. The crowd booed, cheered, and chanted, “All lives matter.” Trump wanted him removed. “Get him the hell out of here, will you, please?”, he said. “Get him out of here. Throw him out!” The next day, on Fox News, Trump was unsympathetic to the protester. “Maybe he should have been roughed up because it was absolutely disgusting what he was doing,” he said.

Advertisement

The same Sunday, in an interview on ABC’s This Week, Trump told George Stephanopolous that “thousands and thousands of people”—Arab Americans—were “cheering” as the World Trade Center fell on Sept. 11, 2001. This is false—there’s no evidence it happened. Trump, however, doesn’t seem to care.

And later that evening, on Twitter, he “retweeted” an image of alleged racial crime statistics from the nonexistent “Crime Statistics Bureau” in San Francisco. The chart—which also depicts a (presumably black) gang member holding a gun—claims that 81 percent of white Americans are killed by blacks, and that 97 percent of black Americans are also killed by blacks. This is also racist, and it’s also false: According to the latest homicide data from the FBI, 82 percent of whites in 2014 were killed by whites, and 90 percent of blacks were killed by blacks. Just under 15 percent of whites were killed by blacks.

All of this reflects the fear and bigotry that animates much of Trump’s campaign. And in fact, the false crime meme literally comes from online “white nationalists.” But while Trump has been explicit with his nativist, and now racist, rhetoric, he’s not an innovator. If large numbers of Republicans are responsive to Trump’s vitriol, it’s because he echoes—in less coded terms—the discourse of much of right-wing media.

In conservative entertainment, race panic sells. And if you’ve watched Fox News at all in the past seven years, followed websites like Breitbart, or listened to conservative talk radio, you’ve experienced it.

Advertisement

During his heyday in 2009, Glenn Beck warned that President Obama had a “deep-seated hatred for white people” and that the Affordable Care Act was a stealth vehicle for reparations. “[T]his is what he said on the campaign trail—he’s not for reparations because they don’t go far enough,” explained Beck to his audience. “We need health care.” Echoing him, Rush Limbaugh urged his listeners to stay alert, since—in the age of Obama—“The days of [minorities] not having any power are over, and they are angry … And they want to use their power as a means of retribution. That’s what Obama’s about, gang.”

The next year, Fox ran hyped coverage of the “New Black Panther Party,” a small extremist group accused of election intimidation. The actual incident was minor—two men brandishing a nightstick at a heavily Democratic polling place in Philadelphia in 2008—but Fox’s Megyn Kelly, who hyped the story that year, made it a harbinger of anti-white terror. As David Weigel wrote at the time for Andrew Sullivan’s Daily Dish, “Watch her broadcasts and you become convinced that the New Black Panthers are a powerful group that hate white people and operate under the protection of Eric Holder’s DOJ.”

During George Zimmerman’s 2013 trial for the shooting of Trayvon Martin, the network moved to constant coverage of “black-on-black” and, especially, “black-on-white” crime. One story—the murder of Christopher Lane, an Australian exchange student in Oklahoma, by a group of black and white teens—received special attention, including segments on an alleged epidemic of black crime against whites. “Look, the most common form of interracial hate crime is black on white,” said Pat Buchanan during a segment with Greta van Susteren. “The idea of racial hate crimes is 40 times more prevalent in the black community than the white community. And nobody talks about it.”

Likewise, at popular right-wing websites like Breitbart and Human Events, writers warned their readers of the “knockout game,” where black teens would attack unsuspecting whites with a knockout punch to the head. “Coming soon to a city near you: The knockout game,” reads one headline among many. On any given day, conservative personalities like Bill O’Reilly and Sean Hannity are denouncing “thugs” and “thug culture,” while mainstream conservative writers are warning of crime waves sparked by black political activism.

Advertisement

All of this is also true for immigration coverage. Fox personalities, in particular, routinely disparage Latin American and Hispanic immigrants as vectors for crime and disease. “Sadly, people are murdered all the time by illegals,” declared Fox & Friends’ Steve Doocy in one segment. And on his radio show, defending Trump, Hannity has denounced immigrants in similar terms as the presidential candidate. “You want to talk about crime? Well what do you think—who’s coming from Latin America and Mexico? Are they rich, successful Mexicans, Nicaraguans, El Salvador residents? No! Why would they leave if they’re so successful?”

And most recently, Fox News hosted a forum on Islam in public schools, where host Keith Ablow demanded that schools teach students that Muslims are “on the march where they’d like to destroy the United States.”

This material just scratches the surface of the race panic that’s ubiquitious throughout conservative media, from breathless coverage of Black Lives Matter on Fox News (a “hate group” that’s “like the Ku Klux Klan”) and fearmongering on immigrant crime from conservative radio hosts, to race-baiting on conservative websites. And it reaches millions of Americans, many of them Republicans, who listen and watch it as part of their daily lives.

Of course Trump would sound off on immigrant crime and disloyal Muslims and criminal blacks. He is fundamentally an entertainer, and in conservative entertainment, those are the money shots: The stories that capture attention and drive ratings. And on the same score, his supporters—the tens of thousands of people who show up for his rallies—are thrilled to hear them.