But the libertarians never gave up. After the 2012 elections, which plenty of conservatives blamed on Mitt Romney’s cufflinked public image, Rep. Jeb Hensarling, an Ex-Im critic, took over the House Financial Services Committee. Throughout 2013, into 2014, Heritage Action and David Koch’s Americans for Prosperity worked with the libertarians who’d always hated Ex-Im. AFP went for the giving-money-to-foreigners angle. “Washington politicians have sent billions to countries like China, Russia, Venezuela, and Saudi Arabia,” tsk-tsked a narrator in a recent video, “through the taxpayer-backed Export-Import Bank.”
In 2013 a polling group called Public Notice created a virality-destined parody of 1980s action figures—the Kronies—who personified all the ways that rent-seeking ripped Americans off. Captain Corn represented mandates for ethanol (“You don’t want me, but you can’t stop me!”). Bankor represented the beneficiaries of TARP (“Oh no, I’m underwater, I need a bailout!”). After months of dormancy, after the Koch-funded Generation Opportunity had taken over the property, the Kronies returned in a cartoon about convincing dumb members of Congress to back Ex-Im.
For a long time, as candidate Obama had demonstrated in 2008, it was liberals who opposed the bank. They’d scored points on corporations by asking if they were really so poor and beleaguered and ganged-up-on that they needed Uncle Sam to guarantee their sales.
“I think a lot of conservatives are keyed in on this issue now because the automatic expiration creates a situation where you can actually end a government program through inaction—which in this town is a whole lot easier than accomplishing something that required legislation,” explains Phil Kerpen. “There has always been hostility to Ex-Im among libertarians and free-marketeers, but Obama's lightning-rod loans to Solyndra and Petrobras have made it easier to message to a broader audience.”
When you spend years crafting an argument, its success looks almost eerily speedy—almost accidental. On June 22, Rep. Kevin McCarthy, the new House majority leader, stepped gently over Eric Cantor’s corpse and told Fox News that he would kill the “crony capitalism” of Ex-Im.
On June 25, Hensarling held a well-covered hearing on the bank, tarring it as a “sweetheart deal” that only benefited companies “like Boeing, General Electric, Bechtel, and Caterpillar.” Republicans spent a day decrying “crony capitalism.” Democrats, meanwhile, pleaded for everyone to imagine the horror of a world without Boeing. (Pause to consider the irony of Republicans attacking Boeing as Democrats defend it.)
Less than a week later, in an NBC News interview, the roles had reversed so completely that Bill Clinton was chiding Republicans for even talking about ending Ex-Im. “That’s not a Wall Street crony capitalism deal!” he said. “That's a financing device that allows us to compete with the 60 other countries of the world who are trying to save jobs in their countries.”
In six short years, the bank had gone from a Democratic target, to a quixotic libertarian target, to a political loser. The Chamber of Commerce was already watching immigration reform flail, thwarted by a Republican House it had helped elect. Now it is having to fight for Ex-Im?
“It’s unfortunate that we have to do this in an election year,” says Christopher Wenk, senior director of international policy at the Chamber of Commerce. “This really is an inside-the-Beltway game that’s being played right now. We’re in a difficult place right now, but we’re pushing. I don’t sense that there’s a massive grassroots opposition to Ex-Im. I sense there are groups in town that feel really strongly about Ex-Im.”
The Chamber still might win the battle to save Ex-Im. Wenk explained that key Republicans (41 so far) have committed to Ex-Im in the House, which is enough if all Democrats join them.
Even if the bank survives the vote, the Koch network and libertarians will have won the rhetorical battle, having put the onus of defending “crony capitalism” on Democrats. An issue too small to notice when Obama put it in a stump speech would have become a growing burden for his party.
“We at the Club think the small things matter,” says Chris Chocola. “If you can’t accomplish the small things, you’re never going to accomplish the big things.”
TODAY IN SLATE
I was hit by a teacher in an East Texas public school. It taught me nothing.
Chief Justice John Roberts Says $1,000 Can’t Buy Influence in Congress. Looks Like He’s Wrong.
After This Merger, One Company Could Control One-Third of the Planet's Beer Sales
Hidden Messages in Corporate Logos
If You’re Outraged by the NFL, Follow This Satirical Blowhard on Twitter
Giving Up on Goodell
How the NFL lost the trust of its most loyal reporters.