Plenty of reporters went to an Ohio rally for Romney where these workers were used as props. They mostly just took filtered Instagrams of them and hopped back on the plane. MacGillis followed the pay stubs.
Meet the Ohio Voters Who Are Killing Romney’s Campaign
Molly Ball, Atlantic
The campaign’s most consistently wrong pundits, like the New Republic’s Bill Galston, eschewed reporting for stereotypes. How could anyone explain Obama’s strong poll numbers in Ohio? Wasn’t he bleeding white voters? Ball, one of the great middle-to-long-form writers on the campaign, headed to Belmont County in southeastern Ohio and actually interviewed those mysterious creatures. On their lawns!
"I think Obama's more for the regular working class people, and Romney's for the big business and the well-to-do," said Eric Burkhead, the road and cemetery superintendent for Kirkwood Township, working on a truck in the gravel driveway of the local garage. The 66-year-old didn't like what he saw happening with coal and wasn't wild about Obamacare, but he planned to vote for Obama.
On Election Day, Belmont did turn red and broke for Romney by eight points. But only 30,717 voters turned out, down nearly 2,000 from four years earlier—which sort of proved Ball’s point. The Real American surge to Romney just wasn’t there.
The Incredibly Dumb Political Spending of 2012
Ben Smith, Buzzfeed
Before it was conventional wisdom, Smith poked a few holes in the fundraiser curtains. Did mega-donors make it easier for Mitt Romney to catch up with Barack Obama? Yes. Did they know what they were doing? Not really. But strategists knew how to create that fantasy and get paid for it.
What the SuperPACs are using to fill that gap is hardly the laser-focused, hard-hitting stuff of textbook campaigns. Instead it’s a welter of mixed messages. One pre-convention week in August, for instance, the Romney campaign was focused on what his aides said was the most effective ad of the cycle, an attack on Obama for weakening some work requirements in the federal welfare law. But the SuperPACs were offering an array of different messages: American Crossroads was attacking Obama over the deficit; Americans for Prosperity was dwelling on a failed solar energy company, Solyndra; and Restore Our Future was talking about jobs.
Beware the Crowdsmanship: When It Comes to Campaign Rallies, Does Size Matter?
Robert Mann, bobmannblog.com
The Romney campaign tried and tried to convince reporters that a surge of unpollable momentum was going to tip the election their way. Their final evidence: Huge crowds in swing states, led by a crowd of as many as 30,000 people in the Cincinnati suburb of West Chester. (I was at that rally and met a decent number of out-of-staters who just wanted to see Romney.) Standing alone in a corner, with a stack of old Life and Time pieces about older doomed campaigns, was Robert Mann.
All the boasting and exaggerations of campaign flacks, and the creative work of Photoshop artists, should give political reporters pause. Many of them live in a protective bubble supplied by the candidate, so it’s understandable that they will occasionally be susceptible to the spin. But that makes it all the more important to be careful and resist the urge to read too much into the size of campaign crowds in the waning days of a presidential campaign. Even losing campaigns, it seems, are adept at turning out huge crowds as Election Day approaches.
Why Obama Is Better at Getting Out the Vote
Sasha Issenberg, Slate
The best and most consistently correct reporter on voter turnout models was my colleague at this magazine. He published one book (The Victory Lab) and a series of pieces that effectively predicted how strong the Obama-Biden ground game would be. His final pre-election take explained it all, slicing through a bunch of puffy spin about the GOP campaigns and explaining why OFA’s data were so dominating.
McCain’s Last Laugh
Robert Costa, National Review
It’s hard to pick just one article by Robert Costa, an insanely industrious campaign reporter. Pick any key moment from the primary or the general or Wisconsin’s two-year Ragnarok, and Costa was probably there, with solid inside sources. (See his story on Romney’s debate win, filed five or six minutes after Denver.) This piece demonstrates just how haphazard and confident the Romney campaign was, while giving us, simultaneously, a glimpse at Mitt Romney’s future and at the future awaiting Barack Obama when ever-more-embittered Republicans welcome him back.
“It’s like the old horse that draws the milk wagon,” McCain tells me, when I pull him aside near the Legion’s noisy bar. “I feel at home here and places like it. It’s very nostalgic in some ways, especially today.” Of course, he’ll always have some regrets about his presidential campaign, but to him, bitterness is a choice. “I’ve watched other defeated candidates, for the presidency and other offices, and you almost feel sad,” he says. “They go into a shell and get angry. But you know what? Life is too short. I mean, my gosh, you can’t just stay angry.”
The Real Reasons You Waited Hours in Line To Vote
Richard Pildes, Atlantic
The great lasting irony of the 2012 might be this: Republican governors who passed voting rights restrictions can’t claim credit for flipping any election results, and that will make it easier for them to keep on passing restrictions. Wisconsin’s Scott Walker is already talking about restricting same-day voter registration, even though there’s zero proof it caused any problems or restricted fraudulent votes. Piles, who advised the Obama campaign on legal issues, does a good, hands-off job of explaining just how harebrained laws and incompetent officials ruin our elections.
[P]oll workers now have to apply state election law for regular voters, the federal Help America Vote Act for those who are going to cast provisional ballots, and absentee-ballot laws for in-person absentee voting. Each category of voting has its own distinct set of rules to be mastered. Every additional layer of complexity creates more capacity to confuse poll workers and slow down the voting process, even if the law, such as the Help America Vote Act, is well intentioned. We have to assess the costs and benefits of these laws more fully.
Absent a crisis, absent anybody talking about it, we probably won’t. Here’s a good way to fix that: Bring it up when you’re trying to impress your wife’s irritable Republican aunt. Make a convert. “Why can’t those dumb Floridians vote?” shouldn’t be the story. “Why does anyone have to wait four hours to vote” is the story.
TODAY IN SLATE
Don’t Expect Adrian Peterson to Go to Prison
In much of America, beating your children is perfectly legal.
Ken Burns on Why Teddy Roosevelt Would Never Get Elected in 2014
Cops Briefly Detain Django Unchained Actress Because They Thought She Was a Prostitute
Minimalist Cocktail Posters Make Mixing Drinks a Cinch
How the Apple Watch Will Annoy Us
A glowing screen attached to someone else’s wrist is shinier than all but the blingiest of jewels.
Rainbow Parties and Sex Bracelets
Where teenage sex rumors come from—and why they’re bad for parents and kids.
You Had to Be There
What we can learn from things that used to be funny.