If Mitt can’t connect with Michigan Republicans, who can he connect with?

Who's winning, who's losing, and why.
Feb. 27 2012 1:22 PM

I’m One of You! No, Really!

Romney and Santorum are desperately trying to connect with voters. But if Mitt fails, it could be fatal.

Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum in Michigan
Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum in Michigan

Photographs by Bill Pugliano/Getty Images.

Mitt Romney reminds voters at every campaign stop in Michigan that he is a local boy. He points out school friends, the cemetery where his parents are buried—his father picked the plot because it was the cheapest—and talks about vacations they took in his family’s rambler. In Traverse City on Sunday, he delighted the packed house on how he stole his first kiss from his wife Ann on a beach down the road. It seems to be working. "He's a lot less stiff," says Bill Vettel after hearing Romney speak Saturday at a college in Flint, Mich. "He's more like someone you could like." Sunday, after a well-attended Traverse City rally, Marve Schrebe is energized by Romney's performance. "If he would come on television and make a presentation like this one and unleash his soul, it would be great!"

John Dickerson John Dickerson

John Dickerson is Slate's chief political correspondent and author of On Her Trail. Read his series on the presidency and on risk. Follow him on Twitter.

Rick Santorum can't claim local roots, but he speaks to voters where they live, channeling their anger and frustration with government. His audiences shout out in agreement as he highlights the Obama administration's disrespect for people of faith or its disregard for the Constitution. They react with gasps when he lists the most recent offenses to the traditional American way of life. "I like his values and passion," says Marge McCulloch. Most voters who support Santorum say the same thing: They like his personal qualities.

Trust me, I'm one of you.


Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum are offering a different version of the same message. The polls in Michigan show that the race is essentially tied. Both candidates say they are the true conservative. They both promise to tell the truth. They say their opponents will waiver under pressure. Why should a voter think either one is on the level? A shared connection—either of conviction or background—might make the difference. He is one of us. He won't let me down.

In the battle to pitch themselves as the true conservative, Santorum clearly makes the stronger case. In Traverse City Sunday night, he was introduced to the crowd as a "warrior for life." The first half of his hourlong speech was a defense of religion in public life. That morning he had defended his comments that John Kennedy's speech about the separation between church and state had made him want to throw up. "That is France, not America," he said of Kennedy's claim. "Look what happened in France. A group of people who now no longer have to respect anybody’s rights, it’s whatever the government says you have the right to is what you have the right to. [It] results in tyranny." That's the mindset of the Obama administration, he claims. "They are also going to force people of faith to adopt their secular values, that if people of faith don’t agree with the secular values of this administration then you will be punished."

Santorum praises the Tea Party and wraps himself in their message of returning to the Constitution, but it's a bit of sleight of hand. Tea Party supporters are almost totally focused on shrinking government. That's not Santorum's message. His pitch is about values. "He is a Christian," says Art Bak, the owner of a flag company. "He upholds Christian principles our country was founded on." Scott Johnson, who wrote a check to Santorum for $100, said he wants Santorum to help "bring back the old United States."

Santorum is pugnacious, describing a president who sniffs at the things they hold most sacred. "The President of the United States said the other day that every child in America should go to college. What a snob." Santorum says the administration is mocking them. "You will be fined. You will be held up for ridicule," he says of health care provisions that conflict with religious views. "Never before in the history of this country have we seen anything like this. Yet the president sort of laughs it off."

A Romney staffer attending the Santorum event quips that he didn't talk about jobs for the first half-hour. It's true, and Santorum can hardly blame the media for making him talk about social issues. He's clearly choosing to hammer away on social issues in Michigan. It makes sense, though. He's setting the hook. With an audience alive to the mingled threats from the Obama administration’s overreach, he then pivoted to Romney, explaining why he is too weak for such a dire moment. He won't be able to draw a contrast with Obama because Romney's Massachusetts health care plan, support for the Wall Street bailout, and belief in global warming make him too similar. That's what makes Santorum more electable. "I like this term resolute that he used the other night," he says, speaking of Romney. "Maybe he doesn’t understand what the term resolute means. But it means that you’re supposed to have sort of a resolve, a consistent pattern of beliefs."

Santorum's reasoning about Romney is reaching his audience. "Mitt Romney has too much baggage," says Bob Hammond, a 63-year-old civil engineer. "If Mitt Romney is the candidate, the comparisons between Romneycare and Obamacare are too great. It wouldn't be a very good distinction."

Santorum goes on for over an hour. His argument is methodical, but he feels like a talk show host filling time. He cycles through one outrage after another and sometimes seems to be just riffing, showing the audience how clever he is. "Imagine if we had insurance that covered food," he said during an extended lope through an analogy about government intervention in private choice in the health care market. "And you paid—you know, instead of Blue Cross and Blue Shield, you had Blue Cow and Blue Pig ... .You think we have an obesity problem now?"