Not Every Mormon Holds the Same Beliefs as Mitt Romney

Who's winning, who's losing, and why.
Jan. 12 2012 4:15 PM

Not Just a Bunch of Mitt Romneys

A new survey reveals that Mormons’ beliefs aren’t always what you’d predict.

Mitt Romney.
Mitt Romney's candidacy has brought considerable attention to and interest in to Mormon beliefs.

Justin Sullivan/Getty Images.

When it comes to the public perception of Mormonism, Mitt Romney is both a blessing and a curse. He is responsible for a sizable portion of the potentially illuminating attention that’s being lavished on his religion. But his presence also shapes the conversation about Mormonism to such a degree that even a significant sociological document like Pew’s “Mormons in America”—the first “nationally representative survey focused exclusively on Mormons” to be published “by a non-LDS research organization”—can’t emerge from the candidate’s shadow. (Disclosure: Though I haven’t seen Mitt Romney in several years, I spent much of my adolescence at the Romney household, as Mitt’s son Ben was one of my best childhood friends.)

David Haglund David Haglund

David Haglund is a senior editor at Slate. He runs Brow Beat, Slate's culture blog.

Consider this AP story, which mentions Romney in the second paragraph and largely considers Mormonism in light of electoral politics. “About 77 percent of Mormons in the survey identify with or lean toward the Republican Party,” the AP reports,

and most hold much stronger conservative views than the general public. Three-quarters support a smaller government that provides fewer services. The same percentage say having an abortion is morally wrong. Two-thirds believe homosexuality should be discouraged.

While these facts are worth noting, the Pew report, read more closely, complicates the identification of Mormons with the Republican Party, and highlights aspects of the faith that most Americans are likely unaware of.

Advertisement

For instance: Nearly as many Mormons said that “working to help the poor” is essential to being a “good Mormon” (73 percent) as believing “Joseph Smith saw God the Father and Jesus Christ” (80 percent). By contrast, just less than half of Mormons believe that abstaining from coffee and tea is essential to being a good Mormon, and 32 percent rate “not watching R-rated movies” as essential.

Those familiar with the Mormon “Law of Consecration” will be less surprised at this result than those whose knowledge of Mormons comes primarily from following the Republican primaries. That law is laid out in one of the major Mormon scriptures, a book of modern revelations called the Doctrine & Covenants, in which Joseph Smith is instructed by God that “thou wilt remember the poor, and consecrate of thy properties for their support that which thou hast to impart unto them, with a covenant and a deed which cannot be broken.” This revelation led to the establishment of a communitarian system among the early Mormons called the United Order. That experiment didn’t last long, but the Law of Consecration is still invoked by Mormons in, for instance, discussions of the church’s welfare program. Whatever Mormons may think about the U.S. government’s welfare system, a portion of their church tithing does fund a welfare program specifically for other Mormons—and this, too, may influence Mormon attitudes about the importance of helping the poor.

I also wonder if those attitudes inform LDS opinions on immigration: Mormons, as the Pew survey demonstrates, have a more positive impression of new immigrants than what you might expect from such a conservative group. Forty-five percent say that “immigrants strengthen the U.S. because of their hard work and talents,” while 41 percent believe they “burden the U.S. by taking American jobs, housing and health care.” On a conference call this morning, a Pew researcher said that there is a link between serving a Mormon mission and having a positive impression of immigrants.

Again, those who have followed the church won’t be surprised by this. Last spring, church authorities publicly supported a comprehensive immigration reform bill in Utah that was opposed by anti-immigration activists. In June, the church issued a statement declaring that the “Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is concerned that any state legislation that only contains enforcement provisions is likely to fall short of the high moral standard of treating each other as children of God.” But for those who have equated the positions of Mitt Romney or the Republican Party with those of all Mormons, this attitude toward immigration may seem unexpected. (Romney himself is, unsurprisingly, hugely popular among Mormons, according to the survey: 86 percent of the respondents who were also registered voters viewed him favorably. Only 50 percent of those respondents like Jon Huntsman, the other Mormon presidential candidate—and just 22 percent like Harry Reid, the Democratic senator from Nevada, also a Mormon.)

Even for experts on Mormonism, the whole survey is worth reading. Who would have guessed that Mormons were more likely to view yoga as “a spiritual practice” than other Americans (27 percent vs. 24 percent)? And while “the way Mormons are portrayed on TV and in the movies” is largely seen as detrimental to “society’s image of Mormons,” a slight majority of Mormons say that “news coverage of Mormonism is fair.” If it’s read as more than just a survey of Mitt Romney’s electoral prospects, the Pew study should make it more so.

  Slate Plus
Behind the Scenes
Oct. 29 2014 3:45 PM The Great Writing Vs. Talking Debate Is it harder to be a good writer or a good talker?