Obama's birth certificate released: It's not the media's finest moment, or Trump's, or Obama's.

Who's winning, who's losing, and why.
April 29 2011 3:09 PM

Born Identity

The controversy over the president's birth certificate is not the media's finest moment, or Trump's, or Obama's.

President Obama at his birth certificate press conference. Click image to expand.
President Barack Obama

After President Obama released his birth certificate this morning, he appeared in the White House briefing room to prove that he was indeed born. Still, the robot rumors persist.

John Dickerson John Dickerson

John Dickerson is Slate's chief political correspondent and author of On Her Trail. Read his series on the presidency and on risk.

It was a day for wild exaggerations, or at least the woozy feeling from straddling the two poles of the news moment. At one end: The president named his new national security team, at a time when the country is engaged in combat in several countries. The chairman of the Federal Reserve was scheduled to give a long-anticipated press conference about the state of the economy. Peaceful protesters were being gunned down in Syria. At the other end: There were so many news cameras in New Hampshire to cover Donald Trump's visit there you might have thought that the royal couple itself had planned to honeymoon on Lake Winnipesaukee.

Advertisement

This isn't the end of the world as we know it. But it's not a great moment. And it's worth asking, before we arrive at the next Most Embarrassing Moment in American Political Discourse, how we arrived at this pass. If we're going to apportion blame, then let's be clear about who gets what.

So, then: Donald Trump. Is all this his fault? Not really. He's just producing the show. We're the ones watching, and we're the ones sending the cameras there. And some of us are too lazy to spend time with Google or Dave Weigel's reporting to understand the claims about Obama's birth. According to the Gallup poll 24 percent of respondents in a recent poll have doubts about Obama's being "natural born," the constitutional requirement  for a president.

What is the danger of Trump? That a man with money, the ability to attract news coverage and a crusading ignorance of the facts will hijack the political conversation? You might argue that's pretty much already happened. Sure, Trump has elevated this to a kind of Dada performance art, but for a lot of people the political system is already a joke. It's only those of us in the political class who are just now waking up to this. Part of Trump's appeal is that he is a giant middle finger to the political system—the politicians, the press, all of us.

Donald Trump gives a press conference. Click image to expand.
Donald Trump

This is all very postmodern, of course. Trump is not a champion of those who have lost faith in the system. He's a champion of himself. His views are not well-known. But he is a place for the faithless to park their feelings.

It's also worth asking what, exactly, Trump is defiling. The political system in which candidates are pressed repeatedly on their views on side issues like evolution? The political system in which candidates spend most of their time and energy fixated on raising money from a group of people with extremely narrow interests? The political system that routinely allows candidates to give meaningless answers to questions that they simultaneously claim require an adult conversation?

Which brings us to the White House. The White House strategy has long been to focus on "important issues" and not get distracted by the news cycle. But it is not above using the very distractions it decries to call attention to the issues it cares about. The birth-certificate issue was a distraction, but it was also a bedevilment that could flare up at any time in the future. It was also a political opportunity. In this way the president's visit to the press room was not so much a deviation from his long-term political strategy as an extension of it.

The president wants to present himself as the only adult in the crazy political world: I am focused on important issues that you care about. This gave him a chance to do that. He called out the "carnival barkers," but he also called out the media for its obsession with shiny objects like his birth certificate at the expense of more "important debates." Politicians in Washington weren't going to have any time to address the serious issues, he said, if they were distracted with side issues like this one. "We're not going to be able to do it if we spend time vilifying each other. We're not going to be able to do it if we just make stuff up and pretend that facts are not facts."

Obama has struck this pose before, during the fight over extending the Bush tax cuts and the threat of a government shutdown. (One suspects that, if there hadn't been a crazy distraction upon which the president could play out this theater, the White House carpenters would have erected one.) That the president sought to make his stand on the day that Trump was visiting New Hampshire showed that while he may disdain the political media, he isn't above taking advantages of its appetites.

  Slate Plus
Slate Picks
Nov. 25 2014 3:21 PM Listen to Our November Music Roundup Hot tracks for our fall playlist, exclusively for Slate Plus members.