On Sept. 11, 1775, during the pre-treason portion of Benedict Arnold’s career, he led a force of over 1,000 men on an extremely ill-advised trek through the Maine wilderness and attempted to mount a surprise attack on Quebec City. It didn’t go well. You may use the comment thread on this page to assess Arnold’s military record or to pursue other points of freewheeling, off-topic discourse.

Find previous discussions in the Open Thread archive.

Excepting the entreaty that you remain on topic, all of Slate’s usual commenting policies apply.

If you depend on this community and Slate’s journalism, please consider joining Slate Plus. We appreciate your support!