Lawyers take on Donald Trump’s Muslim ban.

The Lawyers Showed Up. And They Won.

The Lawyers Showed Up. And They Won.

The law, lawyers, and the court.
Jan. 28 2017 10:58 PM

The Lawyers Showed Up

And because we still live in a country where the law matters, they won.

lawyers_lax
Lawyers at LAX.

Kathleen Cullinan

For weeks, we have been wondering about the lawyers. What suits would they file? Would they have standing? Could they have any impact? Saturday, the lawyers showed up. Bigly. And happily, for America, the courts are still independent, and largely allergic to “alternative facts.” This is a country where the law matters and the Constitution endures. And it’s also a country in which hordes of lawyers just showed up at airports to defend detained travelers ensnared under Donald Trump’s lawless and unconstitutional Muslim ban.

Dahlia Lithwick Dahlia Lithwick

Dahlia Lithwick writes about the courts and the law for Slate, and hosts the podcast Amicus.

In San Francisco, the massive crowd at the airport chanted “let the lawyers in.” At JFK in New York, lawyers hunched on the floor over their laptops, filing emergency habeas motions. In Philadelphia and Chicago and at Washington Dulles, the crowds asked for nothing more than this: Let the lawyers speak to their clients.

Advertisement

And in Brooklyn, U.S. District Judge Ann Donnelly, an Obama appointee, in an emergency hearing, stayed a big chunk of the executive order on the theory that forcing the detainees at the airports to return to their countries of birth would cause them grievous harm. The ACLU challenged the Trump administration’s broad and chaotic ban on Saturday morning, and by Saturday night, Donnelly had ruled that no immigrants with visas should be trapped in airports just because they happened to be traveling on the day Steve Bannon was writing executive orders.

The ACLU filed its habeas corpus petition on behalf of Hameed Khalid Darweesh and Haider Sameer Abdulkhaleq Alshawi, both of whom were denied entry to the U.S. at JFK Airport. Donnelly issued a nationwide stay, barring the federal government from deporting any lawful immigrants who had arrived after the ban was issued or those en route. Within an hour, a second stay was issued in Virginia by Judge Leonie Brinkema, who blocked the removal of any green card holders who were being detained at Dulles Airport. Brinkema further ruled that those detained under the Trump ban were to be granted access to lawyers. (As of this writing, those held at Dulles Airport still have not been allowed access to lawyers.)

This was the first time the judicial branch has been allowed to opine on the fact that Trump is president of the United States. It may also signal the possibility that if real, grown-up lawyers aren’t vetting White House orders, they should probably think about doing that.

I reached Khizr Khan, the father of Capt. Humayun Khan, killed in 2004 and awarded the Bronze Star and Purple Heart, by email Saturday night.* Khan and his wife, Ghazala, were repeatedly insulted by Trump after they dared to suggest that anti-Muslim bigotry has no place in America. In response to the protests Saturday and the order from Donnelly, Khan offered this thought on today’s patriotism and protest:

It is every American’s patriotic duty to protest against violations of our values of freedom of religion, equal dignity and equal protection of law. Trump is sowing seeds of further division based on religion, which reminds us to what took place in Germany during and before second world war and my brothers and sisters of Jewish faith suffered holocaust atrocities just because of their faith. We will not let Trump violate our constitution and its values, we will protest, seek justice in the courts, ask congress to pass legislation to declare Trump executive orders void.

Until tonight it was not unreasonable to wonder whether the scientists, the National Park Service, and the good wonky people of NASA, would be alone on the hustings defending the basic existence of facts and truth.* Today, the lawyers joined the fight. Donald Trump has no idea how terrifying a blue book and a Lexis password can be. He’s about to find out.

Correction, Jan. 29, 2017: This piece originally misstated Humayun Khan was posthumously awarded the highest military honor. He was awarded a Purple Heart and Bronze Star, but not the Medal of Honor, which is the highest military honor. This article also misidentified the National Park Service as the National Parks Service.

One more thing

The Trump administration poses a unique threat to the rule of law. That’s why Slate has stepped up our legal coverage—watchdogging Jeff Sessions’ Justice Department, the Supreme Court, the crackdown on voting rights, and more.

Our work is reaching more readers than ever—but online advertising revenues don’t fully cover our costs, and we don’t have print subscribers to help keep us afloat. So we need your help.

If you think Slate’s journalism matters, become a Slate Plus member. You’ll get exclusive members-only content and a suite of great benefits—and you’ll help secure Slate’s future.

Join Slate Plus