Why can't Lynndie plead guilty?

Answers to your questions about the news.
May 5 2005 6:55 PM

Why Can't Lynndie Plead Guilty?

She swears she did it.

Click image to expand. Not guilty ... yet
Not guilty ... yet

The court-martial of Pfc. Lynndie England ended in a mistrial on Wednesday when a military judge rejected her guilty plea during sentencing. England pleaded guilty to seven counts related to the mistreatment of inmates at Abu Ghraib, including the charge that she conspired with the abuse case's alleged ringleader, Charles Graner. The judge, though, ruled that her plea was invalid because England didn't believe in her own guilt. Can a judge really tell someone that they can't plead guilty?

Daniel Engber Daniel Engber

Daniel Engber is a columnist for Slate

Yes. A judge in either a military trial or a federal criminal trial must formally accept a guilty plea. According to both the Manual for Courts-Martial and the Federal Rules of Criminal Procedure, the judge must first determine that the defendant was not compelled to plead guilty by "force, threats, or promises." He or she must then decide whether there is "a factual basis for the plea." The judge makes these determinations by asking the defendant a series of questions in the courtroom.


In a court-martial, the judge's questions must reflect an additional guideline present only in the military rules. For a guilty plea to be factual, "the accused must be convinced of, and able to describe all the facts necessary to establish guilt."

When England entered her plea on Monday, she claimed her crimes were committed under orders from a superior. The judge pressed her on this issue, telling England she could only plead guilty if she thought she was guilty. After a conference with her lawyers, England changed her testimony, saying, "I had a choice, but I chose what my friends wanted me to do." The judge then accepted her plea, and the trial went to sentencing. But when England's defense called Graner to the stand during sentencing, he implied, in an apparent effort to win leniency for England, that no crime of conspiracy had been committed. In light of this new information, the judge rejected her guilty plea and declared a mistrial.

What would have happened if England had been tried in civilian court? The judge would still have needed to establish a "factual basis" for the plea, but the federal rules provide no specific instructions for what this means. Legal precedents suggest that a judge needs only factual evidence (like the prosecutor's case against the defendant) to support the plea—England's own views on her guilt wouldn't matter.

A criminal defendant in civilian court can even plead guilty while maintaining his or her innocence—what's called an "Alford plea." In 1970's North Carolina v. Alford, the Supreme Court ruled that defendants can make a rational decision to accept a plea bargain (and a reduced sentence) without admitting to a crime.

Explainer thanks Phillip Carter of McKenna Long & Aldridge, Eugene Fidell of Feldesman Tucker Leifer Fidell, Scott Silliman of Duke University, and Stephen Saltzburg of George Washington University.



The Self-Made Man

The story of America’s most pliable, pernicious, irrepressible myth.

Does Your Child Have Sluggish Cognitive Tempo? Or Is That Just a Disorder Made Up to Scare You?

Mitt Romney May Be Weighing a 2016 Run. That Would Be a Big Mistake.

Amazing Photos From Hong Kong’s Umbrella Revolution

Rehtaeh Parsons Was the Most Famous Victim in Canada. Now, Journalists Can’t Even Say Her Name.


See Me

Transparent is the fall’s only great new show.


Lena Dunham, the Book

More shtick than honesty in Not That Kind of Girl.

What a Juicy New Book About Diane Sawyer and Katie Couric Fails to Tell Us About the TV News Business

Rehtaeh Parsons Was the Most Famous Victim in Canada. Now, Journalists Can’t Even Say Her Name.

  News & Politics
Damned Spot
Sept. 30 2014 9:00 AM Now Stare. Don’t Stop. The perfect political wife’s loving gaze in campaign ads.
Sept. 30 2014 11:25 AM Naomi Klein Is Wrong Multinational corporations are doing more than governments to halt climate change.
Atlas Obscura
Sept. 30 2014 10:10 AM A Lovable Murderer and Heroic Villain: The Story of Australia's Most Iconic Outlaw
  Double X
Sept. 29 2014 11:43 PM Lena Dunham, the Book More shtick than honesty in Not That Kind of Girl.
  Slate Plus
Behind the Scenes
Sept. 30 2014 10:59 AM “For People, Food Is Heaven” Boer Deng on the story behind her piece “How to Order Chinese Food.”
Brow Beat
Sept. 30 2014 10:48 AM One of Last Year’s Best Animated Shorts Is Finally Online for Free
Future Tense
Sept. 30 2014 7:36 AM Almost Humane What sci-fi can teach us about our treatment of prisoners of war.
  Health & Science
Bad Astronomy
Sept. 30 2014 7:30 AM What Lurks Beneath the Methane Lakes of Titan?
Sports Nut
Sept. 28 2014 8:30 PM NFL Players Die Young. Or Maybe They Live Long Lives. Why it’s so hard to pin down the effects of football on players’ lives.