Let Us Leave Our Musical Islands

What Pop and Jazz Do Classical Listeners Like?
E-mail debates of newsworthy topics.
Nov. 4 2007 7:34 AM

Let Us Leave Our Musical Islands


Dear Ben,

People tend to listen to various kinds of music over the course of the day: rock at the gym, jazz on the drive home, maybe a little Vivaldi while waiting at the dentist's office for the root canal. There's a long tradition of mixed-genre listening in American culture: As Joseph Horowitz notes in his book Classical Music in America, opera houses in the 19th century would offer Don Giovanni together with "Ethiopian songs, choruses, solos, duets, jigs, fancy dances, etc." Yet conversations about music always seem to take place within a particular genre. Our concept in this Slate Dialogue is to converse for a day or two across the walls of specialized taste. I write mostly about classical music for TheNew Yorker, though I've touched on pop. You write about various kinds of music for the New York Times, with an emphasis on jazz. You have an excellent new book on John Coltrane, telling the story of his sound and analyzing his complex place in the wider culture.


We'll probably end up discussing the curiously parallel histories of classical music and jazz in the 20th century—in particular, the nagging problem of modernist experiment vs. audience taste. But let's begin by switching roles. How do you and I listen to music that we don't review regularly? What pieces in the "outside" genres seem to matter most to those on the "inside"? What in classical music, say, interests jazz people, and what in jazz or pop interests classical people?

I'm a freakish case in that I started paying serious attention to nonclassical music only in college. While all my friends were listening to Pink Floyd, I rocked out to Schubert and Brahms. Then, during a prolonged immersion in the classical avant-garde—at my college radio station, I subjected a minuscule audience to György Ligeti's Poème Symphonique for 100 metronomes and John Cage's Imaginary Landscape No. 4 for 12 radiosfriends instructed me to listen to Cecil Taylor and Sonic Youth, which is where my "pop" collection started. For years I steered clear of hummable tunes and polished production; I bought into the punk-modernist notion that any band selling over a thousand or so CDs was worthless. By age 25, though, I'd expanded my horizons to accommodate the Beatles and Bob Dylan.

Classical types have a reputation for being snobbish toward pop. You can find plenty of evidence to back up that characterization, but also plenty of counterexamples. In 1932, the maverick Australian-born composer-pianist Percy Grainger was teaching a music course at New York University, and one day he said to his class, "The greatest composers who ever lived are Bach, Delius, and Duke Ellington. Unfortunately Bach is dead, Delius is very ill, but we are happy to have with us today the Duke." And Ellington and his band came in to play. In the 1950s, Gunther Schuller began campaigning for a "third stream" fusion of jazz and classical modernisms. In the '60s, there was much learned praise of the Beatles; the British critic William Mann proclaimed Lennon and McCartney "the outstanding English composers of 1963." In recent years, Radiohead and Björk have won plaudits from the pince-nez galleries.

What do classical listeners cherish in jazz and pop? Invariably, a little harmonic complexity seems to get people excited: those velvety ninth, 11th, and 13th chords in Ellington; the Beatles' habit of darkening the mood by changing major triads to minor (especially on the fourth degree of the scale); Radiohead's way of spinning through a rich sequence of chords along a pivot tone (i.e., holding one tone steady through a series of changes). Tricky rhythms also have appeal. You'll find younger composers studying the scratching rhythms on, say, Eric B. and Rakim's Paid in Full—if you wrote them down on music paper, they might look like Stravinsky.

This is an eccentric canon, of course. It skirts around what makes pop pop—the kind of straight-ahead, swaggering music that has topped the charts from the Original Dixieland Jazz Band onward. Classical listeners may have an ear for a wider range of styles—I'm an unashamed fan of early Oasis as well as Radiohead—but we seem to single out the ones that overlap with classical composition. In a way, we're looking for allies, hoping to attract fans in neighboring listenerships. Classical music keeps getting marginalized in American culture, and, like the nerd standing against the wall at the cool kids' party, it's always making awkward attempts to strike up a conversation. Either that or it holds itself aloof ("Who wants to go to that stupid party when we can stay home and play Risk?"). Classical snobbery and classical populism may be two sides of the same coin—the melancholy sense of not belonging. But that can also be a kind of freedom.


Alex Ross is the music critic of The New Yorker. His first book, The Rest Is Noise: Listening to the Twentieth Century, has just been published.



The Ebola Story

How our minds build narratives out of disaster.

The Budget Disaster That Completely Sabotaged the WHO’s Response to Ebola

PowerPoint Is the Worst, and Now It’s the Latest Way to Hack Into Your Computer

The Shooting Tragedies That Forged Canada’s Gun Politics

A Highly Unscientific Ranking of Crazy-Old German Beers


Welcome to 13th Grade!

Some high schools are offering a fifth year. That’s a great idea.


The Actual World

“Mount Thoreau” and the naming of things in the wilderness.

Want Kids to Delay Sex? Let Planned Parenthood Teach Them Sex Ed.

Would You Trust Walmart to Provide Your Health Care? (You Should.)

  News & Politics
The World
Oct. 22 2014 2:05 PM Paul Farmer Says Up to Ninety Percent of Those Infected Should Survive Ebola. Is He Right?
Business Insider
Oct. 22 2014 2:27 PM Facebook Made $595 Million in the U.K. Last Year. It Paid $0 in Taxes
The Eye
Oct. 22 2014 1:01 PM The Surprisingly Xenophobic Origins of Wonder Bread
  Double X
The XX Factor
Oct. 22 2014 10:00 AM On the Internet, Men Are Called Names. Women Are Stalked and Sexually Harassed.
  Slate Plus
Tv Club
Oct. 22 2014 5:27 PM The Slate Walking Dead Podcast A spoiler-filled discussion of Episodes 1 and 2.
Brow Beat
Oct. 22 2014 10:39 PM Avengers: Age of Ultron Looks Like a Fun, Sprawling, and Extremely Satisfying Sequel
Future Tense
Oct. 22 2014 2:59 PM Netizen Report: Twitter Users Under Fire in Mexico, Venezuela, Turkey
  Health & Science
Wild Things
Oct. 22 2014 2:42 PM Orcas, Via Drone, for the First Time Ever
Sports Nut
Oct. 20 2014 5:09 PM Keepaway, on Three. Ready—Break! On his record-breaking touchdown pass, Peyton Manning couldn’t even leave the celebration to chance.