Did the Cleveland Cops Botch the Search for the Missing Women?

Murder, theft, and other wickedness.
May 9 2013 2:19 PM

Did the Cleveland Cops Botch the Search for the Missing Women?

They did everything they could and it still wasn’t enough. Here’s why.

Ariel Castro appears in court with public defender Kathleen DeMetz in Cleveland on Thursday.
Ariel Castro appears in court with public defender Kathleen DeMetz in Cleveland on Thursday.

Photo by John Gress/Reuters

Now that Amanda Berry, Gina DeJesus, and Michelle Knight have escaped their captor, some Clevelanders are blaming the police for failing to rescue the women sooner. “The Cleveland police should be ashamed of themselves,” one woman told the New York Times. “They didn’t take it seriously,” a neighbor of alleged kidnapper Ariel Castro told the New York Daily News, saying the cops missed a bunch of warning signs that people were being held against their will. The Cleveland Police Department, for its part, has been vocal in asserting that it did everything it could to find and rescue the missing women. Whom should we believe?

The most relevant criticism of the department that I’ve seen concerns its failure to show much interest in the disappearance of Michelle Knight in 2002. As I wrote on Tuesday, authorities assumed that the 20-year-old Knight had run away of her own volition. While Knight’s mother says she always suspected something had happened to her daughter, the police disagreed. Knight does not appear to have been listed in Ohio’s missing persons database, or in the national NamUs missing persons database. Why didn’t the Cleveland cops pay more attention to Knight’s disappearance?

Perhaps because ignoring adult missing persons reports seems to have been a de facto departmental policy for many years. The lax investigation into Knight’s disappearance doesn’t appear to have been an isolated incident. In 2009, Cleveland resident Anthony Sowell was arrested and charged with kidnapping, raping, and murdering 11 women from 2007 to 2009. (Sowell disposed of the bodies in and around his east side home, blaming the ensuing stench on his aging stepmother and also on a nearby sausage shop.) Afterward, victims’ relatives claimed that the Cleveland Police Department was slow to investigate or connect the disappearances, which allowed Sowell to continue his predation. Sometimes, the police counseled family members not to bother filing missing persons’ reports at all, saying that “there is no use in filing a report if the missing person is an adult,” as the Plain Dealer reported in 2009.

Advertisement

Mayor Frank Jackson addressed the criticisms by appointing a panel to review police procedures in missing persons cases. The ensuing report issued 26 recommendations for how the department could improve, such as creating a dedicated missing persons unit, developing a missing-persons website, and training officers on how to handle these types of investigations. As of April 2012, according to the Plain Dealer, 22 of the 26 recommendations had been implemented.

If these policies had been in place when Michelle Knight went missing, would they have helped the police solve the case or rescue the missing women any sooner? Maybe, maybe not. At the very least, a more conscientious investigation into Knight’s disappearance might have led the police to connect it with the subsequent disappearances of Amanda Berry and Gina DeJesus from the exact same neighborhood. The fact that Knight seems to have been quickly dismissed as just another troubled woman who ran away from home counts as a definite demerit against the Cleveland PD.

Another criticism centers on the department’s apparent disinterest in the tips that allegedly came in over the years about the strange goings-on at Ariel Castro’s Seymour Avenue house. Various neighbors have reported alerting the police to seeing leashed, naked women in Castro’s backyard, hearing pounding coming from indoors, and noticing plastic bags over the house’s windows. The police either ignored the tips or failed to adequately investigate them, the neighbors claim. On one occasion, said neighbor Israel Lugo, the police came to Castro’s house and knocked on the front door; upon receiving no response, they left. (The clear lesson here for criminals: If cops come to bang on your door, don’t answer!)

If the neighbors are telling the truth, then the police deserve to be criticized. But it’s not clear how much credence we should give the neighbors and their claims of uninvestigated tips. The Cleveland Police Department insists that it has no record of receiving such calls. Yesterday, Slate’s Amanda Marcotte wrote about the phenomenon of false memories, and the very real possibility that Castro’s neighbors are unconsciously misremembering or exaggerating what happened.

  Slate Plus
Slate Picks
Dec. 19 2014 4:15 PM What Happened at Slate This Week? Staff writer Lily Hay Newman shares what stories intrigued her at the magazine this week.