Please send your questions for publication to email@example.com. (Questions may be edited.)
Just gotta throw it out there that I'd enjoy the column much more if it weren't so wordy and trying to be funny. I'd change the voice a bit.
Sincerely: Thanks for reading, Josh!
Somewhat less sincerely: Thanks for your input!
Extremely sincerely: For $2 a word, the Gentleman Scholar will address any question of your choosing in the voice of any male English-language prose writer out there—Raymond Chandler, Ronald Firbank, Donald Barthelme, you name it, DM me.
Wonderingly: Is it not right to write about manners and fashion in a mannered fashion?
Anecdotally: When the Gentleman Scholar was but a lad, he once sat at the knee of a wise old newspaper columnist who said, “Style is you finding out who you are and what you’re about.”
Martin-Amisly: "Style is not neutral; it gives moral directions." What is more, I subscribe to the Amis idea that style—contrary to common belief (and I do mean common)—is not something analogous to gift wrap. Style is the gift itself.
Further: Chicks dig it:
Dearest Gentleman Scholar,
I have enjoyed reading your Slate columns about sartorial concerns, manners, and even conundrums of an ethical nature (should that DB leave his hot wife?). I'm writing because in your columns I hear the ghost voice of a much beloved ex-boyfriend—someone who could be your literary doppelgänger.
This particular ex left me to attend grad school. He loved me, but not as much as he loved the freedom to bed the co-eds he was about to meet. Having in the past pulled the dumping-before-matriculation maneuver, I understood.
AND YET. It's been over six months, I’m still not over him, and your columns have only added fuel to the flame, reminding me of how much of a sucker I am for writers. What do writers want in a woman? How do I find and keep one? Do you know any single ones?
Thank you for your kind note and your excellent question, Bianca. I’m sorry to hear of your dumping. The best writer I’ve heard deliver a quality blessing in the matter of break-ups is Michael Lewis. Years ago, interviewing him, I asked a couple nosy questions about his first couple marriages, and he wound up that thread of the conversation by saying, “May you never have romantic trauma.”
I should mention that Lewis has written for Slate about raising a family with his third wife, Tabitha Soren. What do writers want in a woman? On-air experience at MTV doesn’t necessarily hurt. Other famous methods of attracting or maintaining an author’s attention include appearing on the cover of the New York Times Magazine, asking Langston Hughes to set you up with someone nice, giving him a lot of leeway to do in-depth reporting on his bestselling chronicle of the sexual revolution, emerging as a stand-out flapper, and unwittingly encouraging in him the delusion that you are Anne Frank.
In general, however, it is a writer’s pleasure to treasure the same feminine charms and rhymes and mystiques as everyone else; the Homo scribens is remarkably similar to a normal well-adjusted human being when it comes to his preferences in a helpmeet or a bedmate or a dinner date or a hopeless infatuation. Which is not to mention that the most notable wives of the most notable writers form quite a diverse group, ranging from Vladimir Nabokov’s one-and-only (the former Véra Slonim, her husband’s typist, editor, chauffeur, pistol-packing security chief, and all-around co-genius) to Ernest Hemingway’s first-of-four (Hadley Richardson, who couldn’t even be trusted to watch the luggage).
But also sometimes a male writer convinces himself that he’s looking for a muse as opposed to a mortal. There is a kind of scribbler who thinks he needs a lot of Romance in his romance—a manic-pixie inspiration to greatness or a seraphic object of desire exerting divine influence or a bright star around which he may swooningly revolve.
Ladies: Consider exploiting these misguided beliefs at your peril.
Gentlemen: Adopt such beliefs at your peril. The real talents in the muse genre are the Ones Who Get Away. You meet her at a tender age, and then you go your separate ways—you, perhaps to bed co-eds in grad school—and you do not see her again until she’s guiding you through the spheres of Heaven, at which point she is dead.
No, guys, you’re seeking stability. This is one of those rare areas in which a literary fellow should resist the influence of Bellow; a life that involves five marriages seems in some respects unhappy, and fathering a child at the age of 84 sounds no good for either the kid or your back.
Marrying kinds ought to marry only once, most importantly because marriage is a moral contract and not least because it is a financial one. Divorce is expensive; that way lies the fast track to hackery. Reviewing The Essential Mailer, published soon after its author’s sixth wedding, Martin Amis wrote that "Norman Mailer's new book bears all of the signs—all of the watermarks, all the heraldry—of a writer faced with an alimony bill of $500,000 a year." It would be much sounder, in terms of the household budget, if things arranged themselves serendipitously so that you could pull a Thomas Pynchon and fall in love with your agent, thus keeping the percentage in the family. And if you are not the monogamous kind, if you are a bohemian interested in pursuing uncommon arrangements—Bloomsbury group-gropes, or what have you—you owe it to your partner(s) to state the desire early (and often).
(I am reliably informed that, contrary to statistics, the world abounds with female writers, many of whom also count the pursuit of romantic fulfillment among their hobbies. My editor was hopeful that I would be able to deliver “some delightful witticism on the difference or sameness between them and the men,” but all I could do was to offer you an opinion upon one minor point—a woman must have money and a room of her own if she is to write fiction; and that, as you will see, leaves the great problem of the true nature of woman and the true nature of fiction unsolved.)
Good luck in your search, Bianca. Stay in touch! When next you visit New York, I will try to snag you an invitation to a book party or some other event where writers, ever so similar to sharp-tailed grouses and hammer-headed fruit bats, manifest lek mating behavior: The same males routinely gather at a traditional place to perform elaborate visual displays and intricate vocalizations, such as namedropping Oprah while discussing lek mating behavior. If you do indeed go game hunting among book-party animals, remember that you’ll find the savvier young men taking up positions close to whatever means of ingress the caterers are using to bring passed hors d'oeuvres from the kitchen.
As to the question of whether I know any single writers: Yes, I do. Some of my very favorite writers never married. They include Gore Vidal, James Baldwin, and Truman Capote.
TODAY IN SLATE
The Democrats’ War at Home
How can the president’s party defend itself from the president’s foreign policy blunders?
Congress’ Public Shaming of the Secret Service Was Political Grandstanding at Its Best
Michigan’s Tradition of Football “Toughness” Needs to Go—Starting With Coach Hoke
A Plentiful, Renewable Resource That America Keeps Overlooking
Windows 8 Was So Bad That Microsoft Will Skip Straight to Windows 10
Cringing. Ducking. Mumbling.
How GOP candidates react whenever someone brings up reproductive rights or gay marriage.
You Deserve a Pre-cation
The smartest job perk you’ve never heard of.