Was This the Worst Year Ever for Oscar Fashion?

Notes from the fashion apocalypse.
Feb. 24 2013 11:23 PM

Oscar Shocker!

Movie stars rivet the entire world by wearing stunningly conventional evening gowns.

Is it fashion? No. Is it a parade of conventional prom dresses? Yes, I am rather afraid it is.

Don’t blame me. For years I have been cautioning the red-carpet critics against nitpicking and inhibiting any displays of creativity, spontaneity, or originality on the red carpet. “Listen girls,” I would shriek, “if you keep hating on the unconventional chicks—those gals who dare to bring a bit of stylish eccentricity to the red carpet—you will ruin it for the rest of us. You will annihilate any creative fashion content and turn the whole thing into a turgid country-club ball.”

Nobody listened to my warnings. As a result, the celebs—terrified of ending up on a what-was-she-thinking list—wilted under the pressure and became gun-shy and risk-averse. What little daring there was has slowly evaporated. No more electric blue body stockings (Raquel Welch) or hippie caftans (Angela Lansbury). No more delirious showgirl freak-outs (Cher) or dead swans (Bjork) or homemade one-sleeve frocks (Kim Basinger). No more men in Versace chiffon (Trey Parker) or chicks in American Express Card disco dresses (Lizzy Gardiner), and no more Gap Ts (Sharon Stone). In short: no more fashionable freaky fun. No more surprises.

The frocks on Sunday night’s 85th Academy Awards red carpet were so stunningly conventional that it is virtually impossible to think of anything to say about them … and yet somehow I have managed. Want to hear the top trends? I thought you would. Here goes …

Trend No. 1: Being named Jennifer

130224_OSCAR_Jennifers
From left, Jennifer Aniston, Jennifer Lawrence, Jennifer Hudson, and Jennifer Garner

Photos of Jennifer Aniston, Jennifer Lawrence, and Jennifer Hudson by Lucas Jackson/Reuters. Photo of Jennifer Garner by Frederic J. Brown/AFP/Getty Images.

Jennifer was the mot de la nuit: I’m talking about presenter Jennifer Aniston in her red Valentino, nominee Jennifer Lawrence in her white Dior haute couture, Jennifer Hudson in her kicky Cavalli, and Jennifer Garner in her plummy purple Gucci strapless number. Which brings us to the second trend of the evening …

Trend No. 2: Wearing bustier dresses that cause shockwaves

130224_OSCAR_bustiers
Kerry Washington (left) andCharlize Theron

Photos by Lucy Nicholson/Reuters

Stop the presses: Strapless gowns were all over le tapis rouge. Many girls did not quite have the requisite rack to hold them up, which precipitated another trend: yanking your borrowed schmatta in a vertical direction. Kerry Washington (Miu Miu) and Charlize Theron (Dior Couture), I’m talking to you!

Trend No. 3: Designers deploying sequins

130224_OSCAR_sequins
Naomi Watts (left) and Nicole Kidman

Photo of Naomi Watts by Lucas Jackson/Reuters. Photo of Nicole Kidman by Adrees Latif/Reuters.

Fashion designers blew the minds of global spectators by plonking such notables as Naomi Watts (Armani Prive) and Nicole Kidman (L’Wren Scott) in sequined gowns. How come it’s taken so long for designers to recognize the reflective, dramatic qualities of sequins? What’s next? Bugle beads? Satin?

Trend No. 4: Celebrities visiting hairdressers

130224_OSCAR_hair
From left, Reese Witherspoon, Jessica Chastain, and Eddie Redmayne*

Photo of Reese Witherspoon by Lucas Jackson/Reuters. Photos of Jessica Chastain and Eddie Redmayne by Lucy Nicholson/Reuters.

Tonight’s Oscar ceremony saw a revolution in hair: People had their hair done. While Chastain and Witherspoon opted for the Veronica Lake peekaboo—that’s the same hairdo that was banned in munitions factories during World War II because gals kept getting their locks snarled up in whirring machinery—Eddie Redmayne’s do was professionally foofed into an early 19th century Mr. Darcy swirling tornado.  

Trend No. 5: Actors accessorizing their outfits with heartwarming relatives

130224_OSCAR_family
From left, Bradley and Gloria Cooper, Chris and Lisa Evans, and Quvenzhané Wallis and family

Photos of Bradley and Gloria Cooper and Chris and Lisa Evans by Lucas Jackson/Reuters. Photo of Quvenzhané Wallis and family by Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images.

Gloria Cooper accompanied Bradley, Chris Evans hand-bagged Evans mère, and Jessica Chastain rocked Granny while wearing Michael Kors. The award for the most abundant relative accessorization goes to Quvenzhané Wallis, who had an entourage of three sequined family members with her at all times. The lovely Miss Wallis also reaffirmed the old adage that’s it’s OK to wear a puppy purse AND a tiara.

Trend No. 6: Not being anorexic

130224_OSCAR_notAnorexic
Melissa McCarthy (left) and Adele

Photo of Melissa McCarthy by Frederic J. Brown/AFP/Getty Images. Photo of Adele by Lucas Jackson/Reuters.

By being the same size as many of the black-clad PR flacks who shepherd the celebs— I’m talking about those larger ladies who buzz around wearing clipboards and headsets and appear to shop at Eileen Fisher—Melissa McCarthy and Adele proved that chicks who like to eat can also wear sequins and win awards. Bravo, girls!

Trend No. 7: Not being overly concerned about the possibility of a nipplegate

130224_OSCAR_nipples
Anne Hathaway

Photo by Adrees Latif/Reuters

Previous proponents of this trend include Jennifer Lopez and Jennifer Lopez. Tonight’s nipple-oblivious siren? Anne Hathaway in her adorable pink Prada.

More shocking news has just come in: Apparently the celebs will be attending after-parties where they will ingest large amounts of booze.

Brace yourselves for next year!

*Correction, Feb. 25, 2013: A photo caption originally reversed the positions of Reese Witherspoon and Jessica Chastain.

  Slate Plus
Working
Nov. 27 2014 12:31 PM Slate’s Working Podcast: Episode 11 Transcript Read what David Plotz asked a helicopter paramedic about his workday.