Got a burning question for Prudie? She'll be online here on Slate to chat with readers each Monday at noon. Submit your questions and comments here before or during the live discussion.
My stepfather died in January and I considered him more of a dad than my biological father, who left more than 30 years ago. While helping Mom sort through paperwork, we noticed that we could not find the appropriate documentation for his military service—we wanted it to secure a service plaque that you see on grave markers. My stepfather fought in Vietnam and been wounded there. I contacted Veterans Affairs, the school he said he attended on the G.I. Bill, and enlisted the assistance of our U.S. senator’s office, all to no avail. My stepbrother, his biological son, also did research at the National Archives. We both discovered that while our father was in in the reserves, it appears that he never served in Vietnam. Of course, I feel that it is in extraordinarily bad taste to lie about this. However, I choose to continue to think about my dad in a positive light as he accomplished much in life and saw to his responsibilities, including taking care of my mom, me, and my brother (who has special needs). I gently told my mom about what my stepbrother and I discovered. She said she is going back to the VA to have them try another search. I think it’s normal that she would want to exhaust every resource in her quest to prove his story. But I’m afraid that she’s ultimately going to have come to terms with the fact that he told people a whopper. Do you think that I should sit down with Mom to tell her to face facts or let her continue on an apparent wild goose chase and reach the realization in her own time?
—A Conflicted Stepson
It is a dishonorable thing for someone who never experienced combat to claim to have faced this. Numerous people have been hoisted by their own Vietnam-service petards, from famed historian Joseph Ellis to Connecticut Sen. Richard Blumenthal. Fortunately, it appears that while your stepfather lied about his service, he did not try to receive benefits based on this falsehood, which would have been a more serious matter. It’s too late now to find out if your stepfather made up a boastful story as a young man and then was too embarrassed to come clean, or if he enjoyed the image of himself as a warrior, chimerical as that was. You and your stepbrother have sufficiently proved that your stepfather was never on active duty, and this will mark your memory of him. But you also know it does not undo all he accomplished, nor the admirable way he took on life’s duties. Your own biological father showed you how flawed humans can be. So now your stepfather joins the large pantheon of imperfect people. What you have to do is help your mother come to terms with the truth and accept that this failing of her late husband’s is a small thing in the context of their decades together. Impress upon her that the bureaucrats at the VA have much more important things to do—like making sure actual combat veterans are getting the services they need—than running down more leads that will only end up proving her husband never fought in the jungles of Vietnam. Tell her that your stepfather’s grave, even without the plaque you both wanted to affix, will still mark the existence of a good man.
I graduated from law school several years ago and it was the biggest mistake of my life. I had allowed my parents to persuade me of their dream for me—becoming an attorney. Law school was hell, academically and socially. I was miserable and filed the necessary paperwork to leave. My father told me that if I completed law school that he would pay all the loans I took out. I believed him because he had paid for college and he also showed me some of his accounts to ensure that he would be able to pay without bankrupting himself. I resumed classes and upon graduation, when I inquired about loan repayments, my father said that he never intended to pay, that he lied to me to get me to finish school, and that I was on my own. He stated that there was nothing I could do because there was no contract (obviously a major mistake on my end) and no witnesses, and he doesn’t care what I have to deal with. I am disgusted that he has no remorse and is so smug at getting away with deceiving me. I now have twice the debt I would have if I had I left school. How do I get over this betrayal?
It may be time for you to review your contract law textbook. I actually ignored my own father’s advice that I go to law school, so to find out what legal recourse you may have, I contacted Randy Barnett, a contracts professor at Georgetown Law. It turns out that famous Samuel Goldwyn quotation is basically right: “A verbal contract isn’t worth the paper it was written on.” (As Barnett notes, for precision, the quote should be “oral” contract; I note that apparently Goldwyn never even said it.). Because you failed to get this agreement in writing, Barnett says your father would be correct that you have no claim. But Barnett adds that if you have, say, an email trail with your father documenting that he offered to pick up the tab in return for your sticking it out at law school, you might be have grounds to initiate a breach of contract suit. I know that suing your own father is not an ideal way to celebrate Father’s Day, nor is it likely to improve your relationship with him, but it certainly would impress upon him that you indeed are able to find a practical use for your law degree. Barnett also suggested that a threat of a suit, which would require your father to hire a lawyer, might be enough to shake out some of that money he promised you. What your father did is indefensible, but if you simply want to find some way to make peace with what happened, you have to accept that your father misled you out of a belief that a law degree would make your future safe and secure. Yes, thousands of young J.D.s can tell you that they might have had better luck spending their tuition money at Vegas, but ultimately, the decision to continue was yours. If you are gainfully employed, and especially if your job is related to your degree, then take comfort that you are slowly working your way out of debt. Whether your father can ever work his way back into your heart is not something they teach in law school.
Thirteen years ago my parents divorced after I discovered he had been having a long-term affair with another woman. It left my mom a wreck, and I decided to cut off all contact with my father after he turned vengeful toward me for having found out his affair. I was 14 years old, and a family therapist supported my decision as my father’s behavior was out of line. During the first few years he sent emails asking to see me. But whenever I saw him it ended in tears and disappointment, so I stopped replying to his emails entirely. Today my mom is still a wreck, but I somehow managed to turn out OK. I excelled in my studies, have a wonderful boyfriend, friends, and a good job. My father recently sent an email asking to meet as he has realized he acted wrongly and would like to make amends. My feelings of anger toward him are almost gone and I know deep inside he is a good man. Nevertheless, I’ll never be able to forgive him for how he treated me or my sister. I just feel sadness over the situation and can’t really see how meeting him could do any good. Still people keep telling me I should give him yet another chance. What should I do?
If you decide to have dinner with your father, look upon it as a discrete decision about how to spend a few hours. One meal is not an exoneration, nor is it a blanket forgiveness. You would simply be talking to him, with the understanding that it is up to you to consider whether you want him in your life to whatever degree you feel comfortable. Your father behaved abominably during your childhood. He may be a changed man who wants to make amends and re-establish a bond with you and your sister. He may be the same guy who ends up leaving you feeling sad and let down. But it sounds to me that despite your understandable mixed feelings, you want to give this a try. So see him. Don’t let the meeting become a big dredging of the past; use it instead to catch each other up on your lives—which should cover plenty of material. I’m delighted that you came out of the difficult childhood a whole and happy person. I hope that if you re-establish contact with your father, your mother doesn’t make you feel you’re being disloyal to her. Yes, her marriage ended in a humiliating way, but it’s not too late for her to recognize that she shouldn’t let this sadly common event determine the course of the rest of her life.
My husband is a loving and engaged father who takes great care of our 2-year-old daughter. We have now had two Mother’s Days come and go without his acknowledging the day in any way. This past Mother’s Day we were in the car together and Mother’s Day was mentioned on the radio, so his ignoring the day seemed purposeful. My question now is how should I acknowledge Father’s Day? I realize a marriage based on tit for tat is not a healthy one, however I feel like a real schmuck honoring him when he could not be bothered.
—Goose and Gander
Surely, you two have the capacity to actually talk to each other about what is on your minds. Father’s Day is a good opportunity for you to air your feelings about these holidays, but do so without sounding as if you’ve nurtured two years of grievance. Say something like, “I said nothing about what I wanted for Mother’s Day, and frankly that’s what I got. But I should have told you that completely ignoring the day stung a little. I don’t want to do that to you for Father’s Day, so since you’re such a great dad, what would you like to mark the day? Breakfast in bed? A chance to go to the gym?” I hope your husband tells you that as far as Mother’s Day was concerned, he thought he was reading your signals that this cooked-up celebration meant nothing to you. Now that he knows it does, next year, in advance, do some suggesting about what you would like. And this year, write, “I love you, Daddy!” on a piece of paper and have your daughter illustrate it with some exuberant scribbles.
More Dear Prudence Columns
“Kissing Siblings: My brother and I were always close, but now we’ve started making out.”
“Molesting Dentist: My son’s onetime dentist acted suspiciously, and now he’s been arrested for child porn. What should I do?”
“Say What?: My white boyfriend just called someone the N-word.”
“She’s Keeping It: My friend got pregnant by a jerk. Can she keep the baby a secret from him?”
More Dear Prudence Chat Transcripts
“Rock Bottom: In a live chat, Prudie advises a woman being disparaged for her engagement ring’s small diamond.”
“Liver? I Hardly Know Her!: In a live chat, Prudie advises a woman trying to keep her husband from donating an organ to his niece.”
“When a Woman Loves Another Man …: In a live chat, Prudie advises a wife on how to explain her mixed-race child by an affair.”
“How Do I Annoy Thee? Let Me Count the Ways.: In a live chat, Prudie advises a woman whose husband reads her online complaints about him.”
Check out Dear Prudence's book recommendations in the Slate Store.