Get "Dear Prudence" delivered to your inbox each week; click here to sign up. Please send your questions for publication to email@example.com. (Questions may be edited.)
My dilemma is probably not as unusual as I think it is, but here goes. My younger sister has always seemed to want to maintain a relationship with my ex. (We split up over 10 years ago.) The first few years she said it was because the kids were over there on weekends, but now my children are teenagers and are seldom there … but she goes over anyway. She goes on vacation with him and whoever his latest girlfriend is; she goes over for his birthdays, picnics, whatever, but lies to me about it—and tries to get my children to lie to me! That really makes me angry. First, I do not expect my own sister to lie to me; second, I do not expect my children to lie to me. So … for the last 10 years, we have been having the same argument. I have never heard of someone maintaining more than a casual relationship with the sibling's ex. So I finally told her that if she wanted to continue this, she could write me off. Am I wrong? Should I not expect some kind of loyalty from my sister?
Annoyed Big Sister
You are not wrong. Your sister is either a) hostile or b) sweet on your former husband. It is one thing to maintain a cordial relationship with a relative's ex but quite another to do it your sister's way. P.S.: Your previous husband AND the girlfriend du jour sound kind of wacky to go along with this threesome business. You have Prudie's permission to be done with the situation, your sister, and the whole mess.
I live in a neighborhood where the houses are pretty close together. I like to sunbathe, and the place with the most privacy for me was my upstairs deck, until my neighbor built a two-story-tall jungle gym for his three young boys right on the property line. Now I don't feel comfortable going out there when they are on it, which is pretty much all afternoon. I am not in the nude, but it doesn't feel right; it also doesn't seem right that I should be cooped up inside. It was bad enough when they were just outside screaming and yelling; now I am under their surveillance. Should I just go about my merry way and let them see their neighbor in her bikini, or should I banish myself for the mental health of the innocents?
—Bathing Beauty in California
You are a good soul to consider the corruption of your young neighbors, but Prudie thinks your concerns are unwarranted. With one wrong turn of the TV dial, they could see any number of people without even the bikini. And it is Prudie's understanding of little kids that seeing the neighbor lady in a bikini, no matter how fetching, would come in second to the physical activity of rough-housing and swinging around. At the worst, the sight of you sunning would be like seeing their mother in her underwear. Try to ignore them, and don't forget to use sun block.
I've been dating a wonderful man for just over three months. I've completely fallen for him, and I think he feels the same way, but we're just taking one day at a time. We've both been burned in previous relationships. The problem is: We both have back problems, but he prefers his waterbed, and I prefer my firm mattress. We love being together, but when I stay at his place, I can't sleep. It's a "wavy" bed, and I wind up rolling into him and am uncomfortable the whole night. Then I wake up with excruciating back pain. When he stays at my place, he doesn't have enough room, and he's not comfortable either. Since it's only been three months, it's not like we can go buy a bed together. Any suggestions?
As for ever buying a bed together, Prudie is unaware of a half water bed, half firm mattress, so that's not even an option. In the meantime, to make the pajama parties more comfortable, the solution for you is easier to put into practice than for him: Make yourself a sleeping bag-cum-bed board by wrapping up in a comforter and sleeping on the floor. And maybe he can sleep in the bathtub at your place. (Kidding.) The ideal solution, of course, would be a BIG bedroom and some extra cash so there could be the favored bed for each. Either that … or an orthopedist telling this man to give a firm mattress a second chance. Prudie did not finish medical school (OK, she didn't even start), but it is her understanding that firm support is recommended for people with bad backs. But as you say, the romance is still new, and Prudie has so far not heard of a couple split asunder by disagreement about beds. Good luck.
I have been dating "Craig" for 10 months. (We also dated four years ago before I left for college.) We have such a great time together, and he is the perfect boyfriend in most respects. My problem is that he seems to be under the impression that he loves me, and I know that I do not love him. This has led to many lengthy discussions, and I know that I'm hurting him by not being able to tell him that I love him. I also know that it will not grow into love. He is too needy for me, and I am too independent for him. I will be moving out of state to begin my career, and he has not so subtly hinted that he would like to go with me. I know this will not work, and I have tried to discourage him, but I can't seem to come right out and tell him that there is no way he is moving with me. Is there any polite or easy way to do this? I should add here that I do not do well with confrontations, and I am constantly worrying about hurting others' feelings. How can I be firm but gentle at the same time? I am desperately in need of your excellent guidance.
It's a little hard to see how someone you are desperately trying to unload is a "perfect boyfriend," but let us continue. Life is choices, my dear, and if you can't get it together to level with this man about your feelings (or lack of them), you could find yourself saddled with him for who knows how long? (Prudie is not sure why you are with him now; is he the social equivalent of a default setting?) It is admirable to wish to spare peoples' feelings, but in this situation you are just prolonging the agony. It would be beyond goofy to let a guy hang around because you were "too polite" to tell him you didn't love him. You MUST come right out and tell him that you are moving—and moving alone. You might add that because there is no future with you, he must accept that fact and begin to look for the wonderful girl he deserves.