Shock and Bra
Femen’s punk activists are taking on the world by taking off their tops.
Meanwhile, undemocratic, oppressive regimes see them as a considerable threat. Femen members claim to have been abducted by state security officials on two separate occasions—in Ukraine and Belarus. The worst abduction experience was in December 2011, in Belarus, often referred to as Europe’s last dictatorship. After an anti-government protest, Femen members were dragged to a car by men in black clothes whom they believe worked for the KGB. The women were taken deep into a forest and told to strip by men brandishing knives. The men cut the hair of two women and, after dousing them in oil, threatened to set them alight. “We were psychologically tortured,” Alexandra Shevchenko, who heads Femen’s Berlin office, said of the ordeal in a phone interview. After many long hours, the women were ordered to dress, bundled in a car, and dumped near the Ukrainian border.
Yet many feminists do not take Femen seriously. “Taking off your shirt in order to get the sexist media to take photos of you plays on the sexualization and objectification of female bodies and reinforces the idea that women’s bodies are to-be-looked-at,” wrote a contributor to Feminist Current. Feminists in their native Ukraine are equally upset with the underdressed upstarts. “Femen’s activities give the impression at home and abroad that Ukrainian feminists are rabid women who show off their breasts,” Lajma Hejdar, the head of the women’s organization Women’s Network told Deutsche Welle.
The backlash against Femen is akin to the feminist critique of SlutWalk that questioned both the movement’s use of the word slut and the “sexy” outfits of some protesters. Rebecca Traister wrote in the New York Times Magazine that SlutWalkers “dressed in what look like sexy stewardess Halloween costumes” and added that the movement “seems less like victory than capitulation (linguistic and sartorial) to what society already expects of its young women.” Femen is vulnerable to the same attack.
Femen members have defended their nude protests, which they describe as “sextremist,” on two counts: that they take ownership of the female body and that they ensure press coverage. While it is impossible to deny the truth of their second claim, some have argued that press coverage does not equal impact. As one feminist blogger at the Huffington Post put it bluntly: “Men aren't listening to the message. They are wanking to the image.”
And yet if Femen were really just an organization of lightweights, would they provoke crackdowns like the one that occurred in 2011? As it expands internationally, Femen is well aware that its nude shock tactics can be more than theater, serving instead as a kind of litmus test. "The reaction to a nude protest is a measure of freedom in a country," Hutsol said in an interview with Der Spiegel. "We were not arrested in Switzerland, but we were almost killed in Belarus."
That might explain why, in homage to Femen, female members of the Iranian Communist Party and the Organization Against Violence on Women in Iran organized a topless protest in Stockholm against the veil. The power of nudity in highly conservative countries is further revealed in the wildfire Aliaa Magda Elmahdy, a young Egyptian activist, unleashed when she uploaded a nude photo of herself on her blog. Elmahdy, who sought asylum in Sweden after the photos went viral, meant to attack "a society of violence, racism, sexism, sexual harassment and hypocrisy.” It is no coincidence that she also participated in a nude protest against the oppression of women with Femen in Stockholm in December. Now she is trying to recruit Femen members in Egypt through Facebook.
Feminists remain divided about whether, when it comes to nude protest, the ends justify the means. Femen is undeterred. "I knew from the start that I didn't want us to mutate into a typical feminist organization," Hutsol told Der Spiegel. "I didn't want an organization in which women talk, talk, talk, while the years go by and nothing happens. We have brought more extremism into the women's movement."