Can the government recall a book?

How to protect your pockets.
Oct. 7 2010 5:54 PM

Regulatory Lit Crit

Can the government recall a book?

Southern Living Kitchens Planning & Remodeling.

Can the government recall a book? I've plowed through my share of books that, though heavily touted, were clearly defective. (David Guterson's 1995 novel Snow Falling On Cedars comes most readily to mind.) Friends and family will attest that I've prepared inedible dinners from too many cookbooks to count. It never occurred to me such mishaps warranted government action. I was wrong.

On Oct. 1, the Consumer Product Safety Commission announced that Oxmoor House, a division of Time Warner, was recalling 16 home-repair guides, all of them out of print since at least 2005 and some of them published as far back as the 1950s and 1960s. This was 10 months after the CPSC announced that Oxmoor House was recalling nine home-repair guides of more recent vintage (meaning some were published in the aughts, some in the 1990s, one in 1985, and one in 1975). The problem with all of these was that they contained "errors in the technical diagrams and wiring instructions that could lead consumers to incorrectly install or repair electrical wiring, posing an electrical shock or fire hazard to consumers."

Book recalls aren't all that unusual for the CPSC. Click "Books & Accessories" on a CPSC search page and you'll find 33 recalls going back to 1984. But most of these concerned the physical properties of books for infants and toddlers likely to put them into their mouths. The foam in this paperboard book's binding posed a choking hazard. A red plastic dot sewn into this cloth book contained high levels of lead. The triangular-shaped rattle tucked into the spine of this book contained plastic pellets that could come loose, be inhaled, and damage a small child's lungs. In none of these recalls could you accuse the federal government of elevating literary criticism to regulatory policy. Parents remained free to lay waste their children's developing brains by reading to them about the Berenstain Bears.

Apart from the Oxmoor House recalls, CPSC spokeswoman Patty Davis could identify only two previous instances in which books were recalled based on faulty content. One was a 2008 recall by Taunton Press of yet another guide to wiring your own house that contained "several errors in the technical diagrams" that posed the danger of electrical shock (though not, apparently, of fire in this instance). The other was a 2003 recall for the book Candle and Soap-Making for Dummies that contained faulty instructions for making lye that could cause burns (as lye itself is known to do, making this that rare volume in the series whose title can be taken literally).

Advertisement

These few content-based recalls haven't been terribly effective. "It is illegal to resell or attempt to resell a recalled consumer product," the recall notices all warn sternly, but somebody forgot to tell Amazon.com, which as I write still offersCandle and Soap-Making for Dummies via various used booksellers. The recall's main effect was to drive this how-to volume's price above $82. (Amazon will also sell you, directly, the post-recall Making Candles and Soaps for Dummies, with corrected lye-making instructions, for a more reasonable $13.59). All of the books listed in the Oct. 1 Oxmoor House recall remain available on Amazon as I write six days later, nearly all at low prices, most through used booksellers but some from Amazon's own inventory. Most books listed in Oxmoor House's January recall remain, as I write, available on Amazon, too. I emphasize as I write because these specific titles may disappear after this column is posted. The point is that if the CPSC doesn't check Amazon, which is the first place anyone would look, then clearly it doesn't (or perhaps by law can't) do much to enforce its book recalls.

Is the government really allowed, under the First Amendment, to force the recall of a book based on its content? In all the examples I've cited, the recall was voluntary, as nearly all CPSC recalls are. (Last year, every CPSC recall was voluntary.) In Oxmoor House's case, a Time Inc. spokesperson informed me, "a consumer brought it to our attention and as soon as we became aware of it we took immediate action, contacted the CPSC, and began the voluntary recall." The follow-up recall was the result of Oxmoor House's in-house investigation prompted by the first recall. (According to both the CPSC and Time Inc., there is no known instance of anybody being physically harmed as a result of following the bad wiring advice proffered in the recalled books.)

But one reason most companies that deal with the CPSC tend to agree to voluntary recalls is that the CPSC has the power to force mandatory recalls. Does the CPSC have the power to force a publisher to take a book off the market? "Technical diagrams and wiring instructions that have errors are a product hazard," CPSC spokesperson Patty Davis told me, and product hazards are subject to mandatory recall under the Consumer Product Safety Act first enacted in 1972. But Eugene Volokh, a First Amendment expert who teaches law at the University of California Los Angeles, wrote me by e-mail that

  Slate Plus
Slate Picks
Dec. 19 2014 4:15 PM What Happened at Slate This Week? Staff writer Lily Hay Newman shares what stories intrigued her at the magazine this week.