What would convince you that God exists? A miraculous recovery from a fatal illness? Or would that prove only the astonishing resilience of the body? An atheist friend struck by lightning? Could be mere coincidence. But how about scientific evidence--rigorously tested, peer-reviewed, unrefuted scientific evidence--that the Bible prophesies events that occurred thousands of years after it was written?
This sounds preposterous, of course, like some late-night spiritual infomercial. And yet, such evidence may exist. A few years ago, three Israeli scientists conducted a computer experiment to test the existence of "Torah codes"--sequences in the Bible that spell out hidden messages about future events. When the statisticians crunched their data, they reached an astonishing conclusion: The hidden messages exist, and their presence "is not due to chance." In 1994, a distinguished journal called Statistical Science published their paper. Now, three years later, the results still stand, undebunked. It's an unnerving prospect. If the study is true, science has hinted at the existence of God, has suggested that God wrote the Hebrew Torah, and has undermined our notion of free will. Either the experiment is flawed, or the world has experienced a revelation.
Back when the natural sciences, philosophy, and theology were one great intellectual hodgepodge, proving the existence of God was a relatively commonplace exercise. To the modern mind, however, science and religion talk past each other. Except for the few Biblical literalists who spout drivel about "creation science," most of us now scoff at the notion of using science to bolster religion.
The search for the Torah codes is rooted in the unfathomable theological premise that the Torah--itself a set of five books of limited length--contains literally all truth. (The Torah, a k a the "Five Books of Moses," consists of Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, and Deuteronomy.) This is not an overstatement. The Torah, in other words, is supposed to contain--somehow and somewhere--everything from your Social Security number to the names of all the people you've ever slept with, as well as what you ate for breakfast the next morning.
According to Rabbi Daniel Mechanic, an expert on the codes, the belief that the Torah contains encrypted messages dates to the medieval practitioners of the Kabbalah, a form of Jewish mysticism. The Kabbalists believed that there were 84 coding schemes in the Torah: One of them was equidistant letter sequences (ELSs). Choose every 50th letter from the first Hebrew T (called a "Taf") in Genesis, for example, and you'll find the word "Torah." Do the same in Exodus, and you'll find it again. (This ELS doesn't appear, however, in the Torah's other three books.) The current emphasis on ELSs stems from an observation by a 20th century rabbi that pairs of conceptually related words are bunched together in ELSs. True believers have spent hours counting out ciphers, then trying to puzzle out the significance of the revealed codes.
Not that the codes ever attracted much of a following. Most Jews have never heard of them, and most of those who have discount them as embarrassing numerological hogwash. Even many Orthodox Jews regard the codes as a kind of parlor trick that is irrelevant to the essence of Judaism. Besides, the codes claim is so fantastical that dismissing it as a piece of intellectual knavery may just be the most reasonable--as well as the most comfortable--solution. But what if they do exist?
Of course, any text of sufficient length is riddled with accidental ELSs. If you look hard enough, you can "discover" all sorts of hidden messages. So Eliyahu Rips of Hebrew University's math department and two other scholars, Doron Witztum and Yoav Rosenberg, designed an elaborate experiment to test whether there are real codes embedded in the Torah. They programmed computers to scour Genesis for ELSs naming 32 famous rabbis and their dates of birth or death. The rabbis on the list were all born long after Genesis was written, so no human author could have deliberately encoded them into the text. Moreover, the rabbis were chosen according to an arbitrary criterion, so the scientists were not looking for names they already knew to be present. As a control, the authors performed exactly the same experiment on a few scrambled versions of Genesis, on the book of Isaiah (which, while biblical, is not a book of the Torah), and on a Hebrew translation of War and Peace.
If the phenomenon were due to chance, the authors reasoned, they would be as likely to find an ELS naming Rabbi X near one identifying the birthday of Rabbi Y as they would be to find Rabbi X near his own birthday. And, indeed, this is what they found in the control texts. But it wasn't true for Genesis. Not only were most of the rabbis present in ELSs, but they generally appeared closer to their own dates than to the dates of other rabbis. When the scientists analyzed their data, they found a 1-in-50,000 possibility that such a coding scheme could have occurred as a result of chance.
They sent their paper to Statistical Science, where it was peer reviewed. The editors puzzled over it, and finally, in 1994, they published it. The article attracted surprisingly little public attention, considering its potentially mammoth significance. The Associated Press ran a wire story and the magazine Bible Review published a longer piece, and that was about it for media coverage. But the paper did not escape the attention of the faithful. The Internet is frothing with missionaries bent on using the codes to woo unbelievers. One evangelical Christian site describes the codes as "unrefutable scientific evidence the Bible is God's word." Another site claims, somewhat more gently, that the "mysterious Hebrew codes" have identified Jesus as the Messiah. According to Mechanic, the codes cannot be read as any sort of window on the Torah's inner meaning: "They have nothing to do with the religion, nothing to do with spirituality. All they can do is validate the hypothesis that the author of the Torah is not human."
Acquaintances of mine have become Orthodox because of the codes. I also know of one man who waited until Statistical Science agreed to publish the article before circumcising his son.
TODAY IN SLATE
The Right Target
Why Obama’s airstrikes against ISIS may be more effective than people expect.
The NFL Has No Business Punishing Players for Off-Field Conduct. Leave That to the Teams.
Meet the Allies the U.S. Won’t Admit It Needs in Its Fight Against ISIS
I Stand With Emma Watson on Women’s Rights
Even though I know I’m going to get flak for it.
Should You Recline Your Seat? Two Economists Weigh In.
How to Stop Ebola
Survivors might be immune. Let’s recruit them to care for the infected.
- School District Wants to Censor American History Curriculum to Make It More Patriotic
- U.S. Federal Prison Population Drops for the First Time in Decades
- Conservative Star D’Souza Avoids Jail Time for Illegal Campaign Contributions
- Moderate Chinese Intellectual Sentenced to Life in Prison After Show Trial
America in Africa
The tragic, misunderstood history of Liberia—and why the United States has a special obligation to help it fight the Ebola epidemic.