John Swansburg was on Slate’s Facebook page on Monday to chat with readers about the latest episode of Mad Men. The following transcript of the discussion has been edited for length and clarity. To see the full conversation, click on this link.
John Swansburg: Hi all. Looking forward to chatting with you about this week's episode. In unwitting preparation, I dined at Minetta Tavern on Friday night. They do have good steak.
Marc Naimark: Just when I was enjoying a relatively quiet episode of Mad Men, they did that to Sally! Ugh! Also: "It is what it is"!? And I don't buy “spread her legs” as an ESL issue. Definitely Freudian.
John Swansburg: I don't usually get too upset about verbal anachronisms, but I was surprised by Joan's "it is what it is." Felt very two thousand and late.
Lisa Merryman Hamilton: I think the "spread her legs" thing was intentional, and Marie was just trying to cover it up.
Alex Mizrahi: Speaking of verbal anachronisms, was Ken's line about Megan passing "double secret" signals to Don (I don't remember the quote exactly, but double-secret was definitely in there) a Cosgrovian sci-fi premonition of Animal House's "double secret probation"?
Marc Naimark: I don't get Megan's reaction to Peggy's congratulations.
John Swansburg: I'm not certain I understand Megan's response to Peggy's congratulations either. Later, at the awards dinner, it seems like she's disappointed in herself for not pursuing her dream, which I presume to be the acting career we've heard about previously. But in that moment with Peggy, it's hard to tell what the problem is, exactly. It could be that she's realizing that the triumph isn't as thrilling as she thought it'd be—a glass of champagne, some back-slapping with the boys, then back to the drawing board. It's not exactly Broadway.
Maxine Pitter Lunn: I was happy that Slate's posts pointed out Megan's reaction to Peggy—I had the same theory—that it hit her in that moment (she left the room happy) that it wasn't much of a victory and this was really not her dream. I'm loving Megan—finally a character I actually like.
Laurie Kaufman: I thought that the parallel between Megan/job success and Peggy/Abe was interesting. Initial excitement followed quickly by the uneasiness, as if to say: What if this is as good as it gets?
Julie Kramer: I'm enjoying Jessica Pare's performance (and Megan's wardrobe) but I'm ready to see some of her flaws. They must be coming, right? It seems unlikely that her intellectual communist father would really be so disappointed that she set aside the dream of being an actress.
Jaclyn Mosher: I was actually surprised that Peggy accepted Abe's moving in—were you? She is a trailblazer in many ways, but living together can still be shocking to Catholic parents today, so no wonder her mother was so upset to hear it in the late ’60s. (Also, Glen and I went to the same boarding school!)
John Swansburg: Nice, a Hotchkiss alum! You'll have to tell us if Weiner gets the place right. As I noted in my TV Club entry, I found that game of hall lacrosse unconvincing—should have been more antic. Your thoughts? As to Peggy and Abe, I was also a bit surprised. But I think Peggy sees herself as progressive, and I also thought that she felt like to some degree this was a chance to give Abe the chance she knows she's been denying him lately; I think she feels guilty that she always puts work ahead of him, and this might have seemed like a way to give him a fairer shake.
Jaclyn Mosher: As to the accuracy of Hotchkiss, I will say they got the one-phone-per-hall gossip mill dead right. We still had that lone receiver in 1999, and everyone knew who you were talking to!
TODAY IN SLATE
False rape accusations exist, and they are a serious problem.
Scotland Is Just the Beginning. Expect More Political Earthquakes in Europe.
No, New York Times, Shonda Rhimes Is Not an “Angry Black Woman”
The Music Industry Is Ignoring Some of the Best Black Women Singing R&B
How Will You Carry Around Your Huge New iPhone? Apple Pants!
The Most Terrifying Thing About Ebola
The disease threatens humanity by preying on humanity.
The Other Huxtable Effect
Thirty years ago, The Cosby Show gave us one of TV’s great feminists.