Roger Sterling and Acid: A Trippy Mad Men Chat With Julia Turner

Real-time discussions with Slate writers.
April 23 2012 4:28 PM

“ROGER STERLING IS TOTALLY DEAD!”

Julia Turner chats with readers about a trippy episode of Mad Men.

(Continued from Page 1)

Terry Price: Actually we've seen Peggy smoke a couple of times before, most notably in the wonderful scene when she goes into Joan's office to commiserate after finding out about Don's proposal to Megan. I think I also remember her smoking in the scene long ago when she has to call Don and tell him that she went against his judgment and staged a scene in a grocery store with women fighting over a ham. It ended badly. I tend to associate Peggy's smoking with either stress or a negative event, not a regular occurrence.

Julia Turner: Good points. I thought we'd seen Peggy smoke in the past.
_______________________

Anne Pilikia Bagasao: On a more superficial note: Jane's ensemble that she wore to the acid party was amazing!

Advertisement

Rebecca Koetting Abma: ‎I didn't realize that was a skin belt until she got up from the table. Loved the "belt buckle" on the front.

Julia Turner: I agree about Jane's ensemble. It was I Dream of Jeannie (1965) meets Barbarella (1968). Fashionistas, are there other references I'm missing?

Terry Price: And in addition to Jane's ensemble, was the "yes, master" from Megan to Don during their fight another reference to I Dream of Jeanie?
_______________________

Julia Turner: One natural question is the future for Roger and Joan. They're both recently single—and they've got a newborn together—but it's hard to imagine them setting up housekeeping.

Laurie Kaufman: Although we know that these characters, and people in general, tend to make the same mistakes over and over again, I also can't see Joan and Roger getting back together in any permanent way. I'm sure that he will try, though Joan's rejection of Lane last week, I think, is pretty indicative that she is not interested in pursuing the next wealthy thing to fall into her lap. I think that she is looking for stability—whether it is as a single mother or with a partner who she loves and who is also responsible. Roger Sterling is the opposite of responsible.

Julia Turner: I wouldn't put Roger and Lane in the same camp. For one thing, she and Roger shared a spark that Lane seems incapable of, much as I love him. And although I don't think money would be a motive for Joan, it's worth noting that Lane's not wealthy—note his conversation with his wife about paying for prep school—and Roger is about to get a lot less wealthy. As Jane notes of their impending divorce: "This is going to be expensive."
_______________________

Forrest Wickman: What did you think of how the show jumbled the timeline, all Tarantino-like? (With Don calling in from the later in the episode, etc.) I found it unnecessarily disorienting, but haven't given much thought to it—maybe I was just tripping.

Keli Vøn Schimelpfenig: I liked the jumbled time-frame because it took the viewer on a similar journey as these twisted characters. The whole episode was littered with jarring moments of weirdness that seemed like snapshots from a strange vacation. Then each character had a similar "come home" moment of mental recap that brought no real conclusion.

Julia Turner: The jumbled timeframe also had the benefit of adding suspense to the episode—making you wonder what Don was so upset about on the phone. I wrote down "ROGER STERLING IS TOTALLY DEAD" in my notes at that moment. I'm glad it wasn't true!

Jen Handler: I thought it was a bit of a conceit that did not add that much. That sort of structure would have worked with a big reveal (like if Megan had gotten into some horrible accident), but not just with Megan coming back to the apartment on her own.
_______________________

Phil Rauch: Megan's line about how every time they fight their relationship is "diminished" was ridiculous. I actually laughed when she said it. My wife and I have been married 22 years, and guess what? We fight on occasion, and sometimes the fights are bad (although when I chase her around the house it's for other reasons). Fighting and reconciling is a major part of any healthy relationship.

Amy Boone: I thought Megan's "diminished" comment underscored how tenuous their relationship is. And Don was treating Megan like a child. All of us have been beating up on Betty for her childishness for five seasons now, but that's certainly what Don wanted from Megan—childlike obedience.

Julia Turner: I too am confused about what Don wants from Megan. Sometimes it's childlike obedience, but often he likes that she has her own opinions and ideas. He goes to Fire Island with her. He puts on the plaid sportcoat for Pete's party. He lets her boss him around from time to time, and for the most part I think he likes sharing that power with her.

Peggy Brown Thornton: The question is whether or not his expectations of Megan can grow with her. I know a lot of people don't care for the Megan character, but I like her!

Julia Turner: I've been very impressed with how Megan has emerged as a central character this season. She really holds her own against these characters we've known for years in a way few others have. (Lane-centric episodes are rarely as fun as Megan-centric ones.)
_______________________

Ken Fuson: In years past, I thought it was pretty easy to identify the main narrative engine—will Don and Betty stay married, will new company survive, etc. Until last night, I wasn't sure what was driving this season forward. Thought it would be the decline of Cooper and Sterling. But now it appears the empire is prepared to strike back, while Don, Pete and Peggy are falling. Megan's character gets more compelling each week.

Julia Turner:
You're very right that it's been hard to see what the through-line is this season—although of course Mad Men likes surprises, and none of us saw the Megan proposal coming last year. We thought Don was going to have a mature relationship with Faye!
_______________________

Ken Fuson: Anyone else get the sense that Weiner and the writers have gotten as bored with Betty's story as some of the rest of us have?

Dan Watson:
Well, the Betty episode was one of the worst of the series and otherwise MM is continuing to show that each season is better than the last.

Julia Turner:
Thank goodness for Sally, who can anchor the Betty-centric plotlines. Per Jody Rosen, next week's episode is named after a Shirley Temple film—At the Codfish Ball—so maybe we'll get some Sally and Betty in our lives.
_______________________

Ken Fuson: Hey, while you're here, Julia, just want to say how much I enjoy your group's analysis. First thing I look for after watching the show.

Julia Turner: Thanks Ken! It's a pleasure to recap with readers as great as you all. Thanks for chatting.

  Slate Plus
Working
Dec. 18 2014 4:49 PM Slate’s Working Podcast: Episode 17 Transcript Read what David Plotz asked a middle school principal about his workday.