Just Another Planned Community?

Celebration, U.S.A., and The Celebration Chronicles

Just Another Planned Community?

Celebration, U.S.A., and The Celebration Chronicles

Just Another Planned Community?
New books dissected over email.
Sept. 13 1999 2:56 PM

Celebration, U.S.A., and The Celebration Chronicles

VIEW ALL ENTRIES

Dear Russ,

Advertisement

Since you mention reviews of the Celebration books, I thought that Kurt Andersen's review in The New Yorker (Sept. 6, 1999) was on the money. It had a touch of skepticism regarding the subject (after all, this was The New Yorker), but took Disney's town-building attempt seriously--except for the preposterous name, of course, although preposterous town names are hardly unknown in U.S. history--New Hope, for example, or New Harmony, which Andersen mentions, or my favorite, also in Florida, Panacea.

Andersen raises an interesting point regarding the town of Celebration: That is, it is not really such a novelty. Most of what the two books describe about their experience of living in Disney's town (covenants, problems with house construction, issues of governance, questions of exclusivity, people's motivations for "starting over," and so on) is found in any of the thousands of master-planned communities that are built in this country every year. The experience of moving into a brand-new town is interesting, but neither Celebration, U.S.A. nor The Celebration Chronicles (pretentious title, no?) sufficiently acknowledges that it is an ordinary one. Every year, like clockwork, we build between 1 million and 2 million new houses, the majority of which are in master-planned communities, some of which, like Sun Cities, are much larger. (Incidentally, Frances Fitzgerald has written interestingly about the subject of contemporary new communities in Cities on a Hill. A much more thoughtful book than either of the ones we are considering.)

Of course, one suspects that neither Celebration, U.S.A. nor The Celebration Chronicles would have been written had not the Disney Co. been a part of the story. In that sense, there is a Ripley's Believe-It-or-Not quality to these books. One wishes for a Tracy Kidder to write about the same subject. Kidder's gift is to draw people out, and to keep himself in the background. What mars both these books, in my opinion, is that one finds out altogether too much about the authors' opinions, which are, frankly, neither original nor all that interesting. Frantz (full disclosure here, I correspond with him) and Collins tend to be earnest and well-meaning, hence sometimes a tad pompous. Ross, an academic, never lets us forget that he is from New York and not easily to be taken in. I tend to agree with Andersen, that Frantz/Collins are the better reporters, and have done their homework--and produced a better book.

I'm not sure I agree with your archeology-in-reverse analogy. As an architect, I have seen many buildings, building complexes, and planned communities completed but without inhabitants. It is spooky, I agree, but hardly unusual. Again, with Celebration there is the tendency to inflate the ordinary into the extraordinary, as if the presence of Disney raised the ante, somehow. Of course, Disney's involvement did alter what happened (the school, the town center, homebuyers' expectations). Maybe we can talk about that next time.

Advertisement

Regards,

Witold

leftyesspacer/Slate247/990910_Celebration.jpghttp://img.slate.com/mediafalseCelebration, U.S.A., and The Celebration Chronicles20111

21
103158AMFridayJanJanuary101/21/2011 3:31:58 PM63431202718141751120111
21
103158AMFridayJanJanuary101/21/2011 3:31:58 PM634312027181417511
20111
21
103158AMFridayJanJanuary101/21/2011 3:31:58 PM634312027181417511
Pfalse200110
19
31056AMFridayOctOctober310/19/2001 7:10:56 AM631390578560000000
200110
19
31056AMFridayOctOctober310/19/2001 7:10:56 AM631390578560000000
This week, a discussion of Celebration, U.S.A., by Douglas Frantz and Catherine Collins (click here to buy the book), and The Celebration Chronicles, by Andrew Ross (click here to buy it). Witold Rybczynski is the Meyerson Professor of Urbanism at the University of Pennsylvania. His latest book is A Clearing in the Distance, a biography of Frederick Law Olmsted (click here to buy it). Russ Rymer has written articles for The New Yorker, the New York Times, and other publications. His most recent book is American Beach: A Saga of Race, Wealth, and Memory (click here to buy it).