By the Numbers
Murder by Numbers does the Nietzschean nihilist killer thing; Frailty likes its ax murderers righteous; The Cat's Meow has no momentum.
He nurtures a few great performances, though. It's great to see Lumley, after her years of camping on Absolutely Fabulous, be elegantly, exquisitely still. Elwes is convincingly torn between self-interest and an inability to be a total sleazy thug. Herrmann's loss of control at the prospect of losing his mistress is overplayed, but his recovery and subsequent ruthless assurance is the best acting he has ever done. Best of all is Jennifer Tilly, who's often underrated because she sometimes comes off as an exhibitionistic weirdo. Well, she's a first-class comic actress, too, with a natural slapstick presence. As the vulgar and effusive Parsons, she does pratfalls that are psychologically authentic: She trips because she's so incorrigibly forward.
David Edelstein is Slate's film critic. You can read his reviews in "Reel Time" and in "Movies." He can be contacted at slatemovies@slate.com.
Stills from: Murder by Numbers © 2002 Warner Bros.; The Cat's Meow © 2002 Lions Gate Entertainment. All rights reserved.



Who Said It: Toronto Mayor Rob Ford or Simpsons Mayor Diamond Joe Quimby?
Enterprise vs. Millennium Falcon: Which is the Fastest?
Is Your State Bird a Stupid State Bird? What It Should Be Instead.