Directed by Ridley Scott
Directed by Mike Figgis
Screen Gems Entertainment
"At my signal, unleash hell," intones Gen. Maximus (Russell Crowe), the hero of this turgid slab of big-budget bloodletting called Gladiator. What's odd is that Maximus is the movie's man of peace: He'd rather be tilling the soil on his farm in Spain—"the smell of herbs in the day, jasmine in the evening"—and kicking back under a night sky that's "black like my wife's hair" than out at the far end of the Roman Empire cleaving infidels in twain. But, as one Roman officer puts it, "Some people don't know when they're conquered." So, Maximus must stifle his agrarian longings and do his duty by the empire, burying his big sword in sundry heathens for the sake of the greater good. After all this altruistic hacking and beheading, how does the jealous new emperor, Commodus (Joaquin Phoenix), honor the sterling military leader? By dispatching goons to kill him and to crucify his wife and little son. And how does Maximus respond? This might be ancient Rome, but some things are eternal:
It's tempus paybackus.
The road to Rome is greased with gore, and I'm not just being lyrical. Our Maximus gets scraped off the ground and sold to a showman named Proximo (Oliver Reed), who's the P.T. Barnum of Roman circuses. ("I shall be closer to you in the next few days than your bitch of a mother when you were in the womb.") So, the ex-general enters the Coliseum as a notorious gladiator called The Spaniard in a masked get-up not too dissimilar from the costumes worn by our own more histrionic pro wrestlers. Unlike those guys, however, Maximus isn't big on pointing and gnashing his teeth. He simply wants to hack and behead his way up to the emperor, then meet up with junior and the missus in that big farm in the sky.
Now that's entertainment.
Look, I'm as much of a bloodthirsty Roman as the next male moviegoer. I've sat through entire Jean-Claude Van Damme pictures on pay cable (never on the regular channels with the blood laundered out—what would be the point?). But Gladiator's combination of grim sanctimony and drenching, Dolby-ized dismemberings left me appalled. The filmmakers—screenwriters David Franzoni, John Logan, and William Nicholson; and the director, Ridley Scott—clearly wanted to make an old-fashioned sword-and-sandal epic with state-of-the-art brutality. They couldn't go as far as they wanted and keep their "R" rating, so the violence comes in split-second, splattery bursts—multiple spears piercing breastplates, torsos getting bisected, heads whirling off.
Sam Peckinpah might have made something coherent, even exhilarating, of these battles and even connected emotionally with the picture's paranoid scenario. (He'd have loved all the betrayals.) But Ridley Scott has always been better at foreplay than action: His best film, Alien (1979), is mostly one long tracking shot to the gurgling sounds of an upset stomach. The most evocative stuff in Gladiator comes before the first big battle: the clank-clank-clank of primitive spear-lobbers being wound, the arrows being lit, the soldiers rising from their prayers into a milkily luminous mist. But once the hand-to-hand combat begins, the film turns into a bloody porridge. There's lots of arrhythmic slow motion and a strange, rotoscopic flickering that signals either bogus acceleration or computer tinkering. (A lot of this movie was generated by computer, including 33,000 of the 35,000 Coliseum extras.) You can't tell who's stabbing whom, but there's no avoiding the sound of swords going kerchunk into flesh while blood spritzes merrily up into the frame. (Those computer animators were clearly having themselves a party.)
Virtuoso direction might have helped Gladiator, but it wouldn't have saved it: It would still be a Rambo movie manqué, combining the worst of Cecil B. DeMille with the crudest elements of The Road Warrior (1981) and Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome (1985). I've seen subtler characterizations in Don "The Dragon" Wilson kickboxing pictures. Could this villain, Commodus—the name sounds like Latin for "of the latrine"—be any more repulsive? When he's not lusting after his sister (Connie Nielsen), he's gazing lasciviously on her little son. Commodus snivels about not having had his father's love, but what we register isn't his humanity but his lisping effeminacy, his heavy brow, and his off-center philtrum. (Phoenix's peculiar physiognomy makes him an interesting hero but a too-obvious bad guy.) By the end, he's like Ernst Blofeld crossed with some psychotic movie mogul. Before absurdly leaping into the arena with Maximus, he actually savors the film's ad line: "The general who became a slave. The slave who became a gladiator. The gladiator who defied an emperor. Striking story …"
The mogul comparison isn't accidental. Gladiator plays the postmodern game of having its characters moralize about its own fascist aesthetic, as when a patrician senator (Derek Jacobi) complains that Commodus might be a successful emperor because he "distracts [the mob], brings them death, and they love him for it. He reaches people through brutality." And Proximo tells Maximus that if he wins the crowd, he will win his freedom: "Thrust this [sword] into another man's flesh, and then they will applaud and love you." Are the screenwriters telling us we're no better than the Roman mob? I don't think so. I think they're trying to stroke us, to remind us that we're actually more evolved: We don't root indiscriminately; we root for the good guys. And that blood on screen isn't real!
Well, I felt sated, blood-drunk, and annoyed at myself for staying until the risible climax. True, I wanted to see the last of Oliver Reed, who died during shooting and whose impish turn might be his slyest and subtlest. (OK, it's subtle in the context of Gladiator.) And Russell Crowe is no disgrace. Noting that the actor went from the gauche, chunky Jeffrey Wigand in The Insider (1999) to the strapping warrior of Gladiator with little change in affect, director Ridley Scott praised Crowe's ability to "internalize" his parts. I'd argue, less kindly, that in Crowe's case, the clothes really do make the man. But I don't want to be too flip. The actor works hard and appears to be taking this material seriously. His dogged realism keeps the picture from drifting into Victor Mature-style camp—a mixed blessing from my point of view, although not, I imagine, from DreamWorks'.
A random observation: The hearing of humans was apparently much more acute 2,000 years ago. In the Coliseum, Maximus and Commodus softly hiss at each other, and the 35,000 Romans in attendance appear to pick up every word and register every nuance. Whereas we, poor 21st-century sods, need THX Dolby Surround Sound out of 50 speakers to register someone getting disemboweled with a broadsword.
TODAY IN SLATE
The Irritating Confidante
John Dickerson on Ben Bradlee’s fascinating relationship with John F. Kennedy.
My Father Invented Social Networking at a Girls’ Reform School in the 1930s
Renée Zellweger’s New Face Is Too Real
Sleater-Kinney Was Once America’s Best Rock Band
Can it be again?
The All The President’s Men Scene That Captured Ben Bradlee
The Simpsons World App Is Finally Here
I feel like a kid in some kind of store.
Driving in Circles
The autonomous Google car may never actually happen.