Why cellists like Sergei Roldugin are the most rebellious musicians in the orchestra.

Despite Their Instrument’s Stately Reputation, Cellists Are the Most Rebellious of Musicians

Despite Their Instrument’s Stately Reputation, Cellists Are the Most Rebellious of Musicians

Arts, entertainment, and more.
May 11 2016 9:30 AM

Rebels With Bows

While the cello may sound stately and dignified, cellists are often anything but.

Cello player Sergei Roldugin performs in a concert by Mariinsky Theatre Symphony Orchestra at the ancient Roman amphitheatre in the town of Palmyra.
Sergei Roldugin performs in a concert by Mariinsky Theatre Symphony Orchestra at the ancient Roman amphitheatre in Palmyra, Syria, on Thursday.

Anton Novoderezhkin/Getty Images

Sergei Roldugin, the professional cellist most famous for holding top posts in Russia’s Mariinsky Theatre Orchestra, told the New York Times in 2014 that he was no more than a humble musician. “I don’t have millions,” he insisted at the time. But with the Panama Papers leak in April, a sharply different picture has emerged: Businessmen from Vladimir Putin’s inner circle have funneled $2 billion through offshore companies registered in Roldugin’s name. The cellist has dismissed claims that he is safeguarding funds for Putin, and he maintains that the money was used to buy expensive antique instruments for students.

If it sounds unlikely that a classically trained player of the most stately and rhapsodic of string instruments would be involved in such uncouth adventures—John Oliver certainly found it incredible—you don’t know your cello history. Indeed, if any instrumentalist was going to be involved in a wild international money-laundering scheme, it was probably going to be a cellist. The instrument has a long history of association with rowdy activists, sultry libertines, genre iconoclasts, and all manner of rebellious spirits. “Every instrument seems to attract its own characters,” Matt Haimovitz, a noted cellist, explained to me. And for cello, that means musicians with a strong distaste for authority of all sorts.

Advertisement

This was certainly the case with several pre-eminent cellists of the 20th century. The Catalan cellist Pablo Casals (1876-1973) was an ardent supporter of the Republican government during the Spanish Civil War and chose self-exile after Francisco Franco came to power with the end of the war in 1939. (He later refused to perform in countries that recognized Franco’s government.) Paul Tortelier, a French cellist and noted pacifist, shunned the U.S. during the Korean and Vietnam wars and composed several political anthems, including “The Great Flag,” written for the United Nations. Janos Starker fled his native Hungary after World War II; when he finally returned in the 1970s, he made his position clear: “I do not play for governments. I play for the people.”

Perhaps the most Olympian cello personality of all was the Russian Mstislav Rostropovich (1927-2007), a performer whose commanding stage presence was matched by his advocacy for Soviet-era dissidents. Under Leonid Brezhnev’s regime, Rostropovich and his wife, the soprano Galina Vishnevskaya, sheltered the dissident novelist Alexander Solzhenitsyn in their country house—one of many gestures that led to canceled concerts and recordings. Declared “ideological renegades” by the state, Rostropovich and his family fled to Paris in 1974. Soon after, the Soviet Union revoked their citizenship. It was restored in 1990, a year after the cellist gave an impromptu recital at Checkpoint Charlie in Berlin as the wall was being torn down. In the early 1990s, he rushed to support the embattled Boris Yeltsin.

Rostropovich was not a saint, but his public gestures paved the way for other cello activists. In 1992, Vedran Smailovic, a cellist in the Sarajevo Opera, defied snipers in his besieged city to perform amid the ruined buildings. He was dubbed the “cellist of Sarajevo” and inspired song tributes and a fictionalized novel. In 2015, Karim Wasfi, an Iraqi cellist, showed up at sites of terrorist bombings in Baghdad. Videos of his performances went viral on the internet and sparked debate over the tactic’s efficacy. “Obviously I cannot challenge the bombs with my cello,” Wasfi said in an interview with the BBC. “But we make things normal, we make things worth living for.”

While the cello is sometimes identified with public gravitas—think of Yo-Yo Ma’s performances at Sen. Edward Kennedy’s funeral or the 10th anniversary of Sept. 11—cellists themselves are often portrayed as free spirits in their private lives. In the Amazon Prime series Mozart in the Jungle, Cynthia (played by Saffron Burrows) carries on multiple romantic relationships with professional colleagues, including with a union attorney played by Gretchen Mol. The biopic Hilary and Jackie depicted the late cellist Jacqueline du Pré as a “selfish seductress” who has an affair with her sister’s husband (a debated historical point). And there was Kara Milovy, the sniper-cellist in the 1987 James Bond film The Living Daylights. A 2007 survey of a survey of professional and amateur musicians in the British classical music magazine Muso identified the cello as the “sexiest instrument” and reported that cellists make the best lovers.

Advertisement

Another bit of evidence for this notion: When Pablo Casals was 80, he married his third wife, 21-year-old former student Marta Montañez. “I’m going to enjoy myself,” he bluntly told his doctor and friends. “And if the girl dies, she dies.” The Croatian crossover duo 2Cellos and the self-described cello goddess Maya Beiser are among contemporary artists to embrace a sultry image. Beiser champions modern composers while favoring a high-fashion bohemian look (knee-high boots, edgy downtown designers), and 2Cellos go for guitar-hero bravado; all black T-shirts; artful stubble; and a repertoire spanning AC/DC, U2, and Michael Jackson covers.

There’s even a cello-metal subgenre, pioneered in the 1990s by Apocalyptica, a Finnish quartet that started out covering Metallica songs, and Rasputina, a cello-driven band from New York. Doug Jenkins, the founder of the Portland Cello Project (an all-cello band) believes that cellists are motivated by “an attempt to prove we can do more,” exploring percussive textures or playing in the manner imitative of electric guitars. Since founding the band in 2007 as a way to bring the Oregon cello community together, Jenkins and his colleagues have played jaunty covers of Taylor Swift’s “Shake it Off” and keening arrangements of Elliott Smith and Radiohead songs. Other cello rock groups have added electronic pedals and distortion effects.

If Matt Haimovitz is any indication, cellists won’t stop causing trouble anytime soon. He recalls how during the Iraq War he often performed his arrangement of Jimi Hendrix’s version of the “Star-Spangled Banner,” introduced with commentary about music’s power being stronger than military might. The gesture drew a backlash in conservative communities in the U.S. “I would get booed, and yet I’d do it every night,” he said. One concert hall in Denmark—then part of the coalition forces in the Iraq War—was so displeased by Haimovitz’s gesture that its management asked him to issue an apology on its website afterward. Later this year, Haimovitz plans to release an all-Russian album with pianist Christopher O’Riley that includes an arrangement of a song by the feminist punk band Pussy Riot. “Working on this album, I thought, ‘Putin will never notice,’ ” he said, laughing. “But now, with his best friend being a cellist—you never know.”

Brian Wise is a writer and editor who covers the arts for BBC Music magazine, Listen magazine, and other publications.